Abstract – The study aims to investigate the effect of
collaborative communication, power dependency, and price
satisfaction on trust of individual farmers to the dairy KUD
(a dairy cooperative). This study also aims to investigate the
effect of trust on the loyalty of individual farmers to the dairy
cooperative. The investigation will represented by the 165
individual farmers and several dairies cooperative in 6
districts in Boyolali, Central Java, Indonesia. The finding of
this study indicates that the collaborative communication and
price satisfaction have a significant positive effect on
individual dairy farmer’s trust of the competence-goodwill
and producer’s contractual of dairy cooperative; whereas, the
imbalance power-dependency have a negative significant
effect on the competence-goodwill and producer’s contractual
of dairy cooperative. The finding of this study also indicates
that competence-goodwill and contractual trust of individual
farmers have a significant effect on the level of their loyalty to
the particular dairy cooperative.
Keywords - dairy cooperative; Boyolali; individual
farmers; structural equation modelling; trust
I. INTRODUCTION
Milk is one of the important agro products in
Indonesia. In 2013, there were almost 636,064 dairy cows
in Indonesia, producing more or less 981,586 tons of milk.
Basically, Indonesia’s dairy supply chain consists of three
main actors: the producers (individual farmers and
corporate dairy farmers), buyers (Local Dairy Cooperative
Union or Koperasi Unit Desa/KUD, and milk processor),
and consumer. Until now, there is no portion of the chain
does the producer interact directly with consumers. Mostly
of the producer in Indonesia’s dairy supply chain is an
individual farmer, although, sometimes, their role in milk
production less important than corporate dairy farmers. For
example, in East Java, although individual farmers owned
94 percent of cows, corporate dairy farmers have an
important role because they can produce fresh milk more
than dairy farmers and their fresh milk production is
increasing faster than individual farmers. Then, KUD are
the main choice for individual farmers to sell their milk,
only a few of the individual farmers sell their fresh milk
direct to milk processor. In Indonesia, there were about 220
KUDs involved in the dairy industry with more or less
100,000 dairy farmers as members. Each of the
cooperatives is a member of The Indonesian Association of
Dairy Cooperatives (Gabungan Koperasi Susu Indonesia or
GKSI).
There were several services provided by KUD to the
dairy farmers, among others, providing cattle and feed on
credit, collecting the milk, checking the milk quality, and
paying the farmer. Although KUD providing the dairy
farmers credit, basically, the farmers are independent milk
producers because they have to decide anything related to
their businesses by themselves. In this case, the farmers are
the parties that have full responsibility of running of the
dairy farms day-to-day. The KUD collects the fresh milk,
processes it and then markets it to processing industries,
and in specific cases, KUD market the fresh milk direct to
the general public. The KUD is the biggest buyer of the
fresh milk produced by the farmers. Although there were
no formal contract between the KUD and the farmer, in
practice, the farmers have to sell their fresh milk to the
KUDs to which they belong. In this case, impossibility of
carrying milk over long distances becomes a condition that
makes the farmers difficult to sell the milk to the other
KUDs. Based on this condition, the KUDs have a
monopoly position in defining the price of fresh milk. In
this case, at farm level, the price of fresh milk is decided
by the GKSI and KUD. If the farmers were independent,
the farmers would be able to get the highest price through
sells their fresh milk directly to the milk processing
industries. But this condition rarely happens. Then, after
collecting the milk from the farmers, GKSI sold the milk
to the milk processing industries. The price of fresh milk is
determined by the milk processing industries based on the
level quality of fresh milk. The higher level quality of fresh
milk, the higher price that can be obtained by GKSI from
the milk processing industries. The GKSI rarely can get
the highest price of fresh milk from milk processing
industries. It's because, the level of quality of fresh milk
from local cow is still far below the National Quality
Standard (SNI). Only 12 percent of milk production
meeting the minimum quality standard for milk and to
overcome this problem, giving price incentive to the dairy
farmers is one of the tools that used by KUD to encourage
better farm management practices and higher quality milk
[1], [2], [3]. All of the explanations about the relation
between individual farmers and cooperative indicates the
importance of the producer (individual farmer) and the
buyer (cooperatives) having improved understanding,
through collaboration and achieving long-term working
relationships along the chain. Quality relationship
between both parties ensures constant milk supplies with
good quality and reasonable price which in turn enhance
the milk supply chain [4].
The relationship between the KUD and individual
farmer is that of buyer and seller, and there is no contractual
The (ffect of &ollaborative &ommunication, 3ower 'ependency, and 3rice
6atisfaction on 7rust and /oyalty of ,ndividual )armers to 'airy &ooperative
Case 6tudy 'airy 6upply &hain in Boyolali
A. Susanty
1
, A. Bakhtiar
1
, H. Suliantoro
1
, Christoper 0DQDOX
1
1
Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Diponegoro, Semarang, Indonesia
ariessusanty@gmail.com
104 978-1-5090-3665-3/16/$31.00 ©2016 IEEE