© The Author(s)
Journal Compilation © Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Garsington Road, Oxford OX DQ , UK and
Main Street, Malden, MA , USA
S P & A 0144–5596
V. 40, No. 1, F 2006, . 26–46
Blackwell Publishing Ltd Oxford, UK SPOL Social Policy & Administration - © Blackwell Publishing Ltd. February Original Article XX XX
A Comparative Case Study of Care Systems for
Frail Elderly People: Germany, Spain, France, Italy,
United Kingdom and Sweden
Blanche Le Bihan and Claude Martin
Abstract
Comparative studies of European social policies towards frail elderly people typically focus on the
systems and their implementation. The study presented in this article, conducted in in six
European countries (Germany, Spain, Italy, France, the United Kingdom and Sweden) aims at
comparing the rights of the individuals within the different care systems. The methodology used is
a case study approach, which draws on a series of situations of dependent elderly people. There-
fore, the analysis focuses on the public authorities’ responses – the care packages, which determine
the type of care required and the financial contribution of the user – in each of the six countries,
in relation to the concrete situations of frail elderly people. As local variations are important, in
all the countries studied, local authorities have been chosen in each of the countries. This approach
gives us interesting concrete elements on the services and financial help which can be given to frail
elderly people, but it also enables us to understand precisely the national care systems organized
in the different countries and the main difficulties encountered by public authorities in facing this
problem of frail elderly people.
Keywords
Frail elderly people; Care systems; Comparative study; Europe
Comparative studies of European social policies towards frail elderly people
typically focus on the systems and their implementation, not on individual user
rights. However, existing comparisons of care systems for elderly dependants
(Lesemann and Martin ; OECD ; Jacobzone ; Assous and Ralle
) show that, although the range of proposed services is almost identical
in each country, the patterns indicate that there is considerable variability –
particularly at the local level. Various factors explain these variations: the
differences between the social protection principles applied in each country,
Address for correspondence: Professor Claude Martin, Ecole Nationale de la Santé Publique,
Avenue du Professeur Léon Bernard, Rennes Cedex, France. Email: Claude.Martin@ensp.fr