Flood inundation mapping in small and ungauged basins:
sensitivity analysis using the EBA4SUB and HEC-RAS
modeling approach
Matej Vojtek, Andrea Petroselli, Jana Vojteková and Shahla Asgharinia
ABSTRACT
Flood mapping is an important part of flood risk analysis and management as its result is the
visualization of flood hazard in terms of flood depth and extent. However, flood mapping strongly
depends on the selected modeling approach. Furthermore, model input data usually incorporate
uncertainties that may vary significantly in time and space. In this study, the EBA4SUB (Event-Based
Approach for Small and Ungauged Basins) hydrologic model and the one-dimensional HEC-RAS
(Hydrologic Engineering Center’s River Analysis System) hydraulic model were selected for evaluating
their sensitivity, in terms of simulated flood area (FA) and volume (FV), to different combinations of
input parameters. Results of hydrologic modeling highlight the great variation of design peak
discharges which strongly influence the modeled FA and FV. The sensitivity of FA and FV to excess
rainfall determination was several times larger than the sensitivity to the routing propagation for
two assumed gross rainfall distributions (rectangular and Chicago), which highlights the importance
of the correct estimation of soil and land use properties affecting the infiltration estimation.
Moreover, the sensitivity of FA and FV to the roughness parameter was 1.5–2 times greater than the
sensitivity to the cross-section parameter, yet, stressing the importance of input parameters for
hydraulic modeling.
Matej Vojtek (corresponding author)
Jana Vojteková
Department of Geography and Regional
Development, Faculty of Natural Sciences,
Constantine the Philosopher University in Nitra,
Nitra,
Slovakia
E-mail: mvojtek@ukf.sk
Andrea Petroselli
Department of Economics, Engineering, Society
and Business Organization (DEIM),
Tuscia University,
Viterbo,
Italy
Shahla Asgharinia
Department of Innovation in Biological, Agro-food
and Forest Systems (DIBAF),
Tuscia University,
Viterbo,
Italy
Key words | EBA4SUB, flood, HEC-RAS, inundation, sensitivity analysis, ungauged basin
INTRODUCTION
Flood mapping is a crucial element of flood risk manage-
ment since it provides the delineation of flood depth and
extent in flood-prone areas. The creation of flood maps is
usually performed using a combination of hydrologic and
hydraulic models that is particularly challenging in case of
small and ungauged basins where the calibration of
advanced hydrologic models is difficult due to lack of
observed discharge data (Grimaldi et al. a; Szymczak
& Kre ˛ z ˙ alek ). In order to estimate the design peak dis-
charge or the design hydrograph for ungauged basins,
different hydrologic models are usually applied (Petroselli
et al. ). In particular, simple conceptual models rep-
resent a reliable compromise between the physical
representation of the investigated hydrologic processes and
the limited number of adopted parameters (Mlyn ´ski et al.
).
Regarding the hydraulic part, the first important issue
concerns the selection of the modeling approach to be
used which mainly depends on the objective of the study
and flow conditions. In general, one-dimensional (1D) and
two-dimensional (2D) hydraulic models are commonly
used allowing the simulation of steady or unsteady flow.
1D models consider discrete cross-section profiles for defin-
ing the channel and floodplain shape and assume that water
moves only longitudinally along the river direction. How-
ever, the limitation of 1D hydraulic models is that they are
not able to provide information on the character and direc-
tion of flow as well as the way of flowing off the obstacles.
1002 © IWA Publishing 2019 Hydrology Research | 50.4 | 2019
doi: 10.2166/nh.2019.163
Downloaded from https://iwaponline.com/hr/article-pdf/50/4/1002/584667/nh0501002.pdf
by guest
on 06 June 2020