Comparison of an immunochromatographic card test with
night blood smear examination for detection of Wuchereria
bancrofti microfilaria carriers
S. P. PANI, S. L. HOTI, P. VANAMAIL, L. K. DAS
Vector Control Research Centre (Indian Council of Medical Research),
Pondicherry 605006, India
S. P. PANI, S. L. HOTI, P. VANAMAIL, L. K. DAS
Correspondence to S. P. PANI; vcrc@vsnl.com; sp_pani@vsnl.com
© The National Medical Journal of India 2004
)*564)+6
Background. At present, two diagnostic testsOg4C3
ELISA and an immunochromatographic card test (ICT)are
available to detect circulating filarial antigens of Wuchereria
bancrofti in serum/whole blood samples collected during the day.
We aimed to assess the sensitivity of the new format card test
NOW® ICT Filariasis in detecting microfilaria carriers of W.
bancrofti in comparison with conventional microscopic tech-
niques and Og4C3 ELISA.
Methods. A total of 200 persons were selected from two
villages following a quota sampling design (100 in each village).
The required number of houses was selected using a systematic
sampling procedure with a random start of the first household.
Blood samples were taken from all the available persons in each
selected house until the quota of 100 was reached. The new
format ICT test, Og4C3 ELISA and night blood smear exami-
nation for microfilaria were carried out following standard
procedures.
Results. The sensitivity of the new format ICT test was
100% among microfilaria carriers (detected by both early and
late readings). The kappa statistic measure of agreement between
the two readings of all the samples (n=200) tested was 0.811
(p<0.05). The new format test also reported 25% of micro-
filaria-negative individuals as being positive for circulating filarial
antigens. However, the diagnostic lines were not stable beyond
10 minutes (particularly in the case of amicrofilaraemic persons).
Though there was an overall agreement between the results of
ICT and Og4C3 tests (kappa=0.612; p<0.05), the sensitivity
of the Og4C3 test was lower than that of ICT.
Conclusion. The new format ICT test is highly sensitive in
detecting microfilaria carriers in endemic communities. Im-
provement in the format to provide stable diagnostic lines,
specificity of the format and cost of the test kit are to be
considered before its large-scale use.
Natl Med J India 2004;17:3046
INTRODUCTION
Lymphatic filariasis has been targeted for elimination by 2020
1–4
and India has set 2015 as the deadline for achieving this goal.
5
The
availability of a good diagnostic test is essential to map areas
endemic for filariasis to delimit, stratify and prioritize them for
intervention, as well as for monitoring and evaluating the control/
OA-Ashwani.pmd 1/24/05, 9:32 AM 304
Black
Original Articles