Microfabricated Instruments for Fetal Cardiac Surgery:
Experiments on Haptic Tissue Recognition
Anna Eisinberg, Oliver Tonet
*
, Paolo Dario
CRIM - Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna
Giovanna Macr` ı, Maria Chiara Carrozza
ARTS Lab - Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna
ABSTRACT
This paper describes the performance of a microfabricated gripper,
equipped with semiconductor strain gauges as force sensors, and
teleoperated via a PHANTOM haptic interface. The main objective
is to demonstrate that the force sensed by the gripper, when ren-
dered to the user by means of a haptic interface, can provide a feel-
ing of tissue stiffness that allows the user to successfully discrim-
inate among different tissue types during the most delicate opera-
tions of minimally invasive surgery, such as in fetal cardiac surgery.
Experiments aimed to prove the usefulness of this approach have
been carried out: the system allowed unskilled operators to qual-
itatively discriminate pieces of pulmonary valve and endocardium
(excited from fetal lamb). Haptic response models were created
from the measured data and additional experiments were carried
out off-line on a PHANTOM interface. User trials on the simu-
lated tissue demonstrate the excellent discrimination capability of
the system.
CR Categories: H.5.2 [Information interfaces and presentation]:
User Interfaces—Haptic I/O
Keywords: Microgripper, haptic interfaces, fetal surgery
1 I NTRODUCTION
Nowadays many research efforts in different technical fields are be-
ing devoted to design novel to improve the ability of surgeons to
safely perform precision operations. There is an increasing number
of surgical procedures that can be now carried out in with mini-
mally invasive techniques. Minimally Invasive Surgery (MIS) rep-
resents a key example of strong cooperation between medical peo-
ple and researchers in engineering and computer science. Actually
during MIS a lot of relevant information, useful to help surgeons to
safely interact with the intra-operative environment, are less effec-
tive, such as visual perception, or even distorted or missing, such as
haptic perception, and this results in limited sensory abilities and in
a severe reduction of dexterity in manipulation. In this context, it
is clear that microengineering and microrobotics can provide very
powerful means for the development of a novel generation of re-
search instruments. In addition, the development of specific hap-
tic interfaces that help surgeons to feel the forces exerted by their
microinstruments in a realistic way, is also an important research
topic. In the last few years, a wide variety of laboratory apparatuses
and microfabricated instruments have been developed and became
fundamental tools for minimally invasive diagnostics and surgery.
First prototypes of smart instruments, able to provide the opera-
tor some sort of haptic feedback during MIS, have been devised in
the late 1980’s [3]. Most progresses have been achieved during the
1990’s, both in the field of visual and haptic feedback. Concerning
*
e-mail: oly@sssup.it
the visualization issue, enhancement of current performance in la-
paroscopic surgery could be achieved either by higher definition im-
ages from the vision system, or by employing different techniques.
An example can be found in [11], where an infrared imaging-based
system is illustrated. The use of stereoscopic head mounted dis-
plays (HMDs) is also considered to be helpful for improving the
surgeons’ sense of immersion during task execution [7]. On the
other hand, HMDs can cause serious real world occlusion prob-
lems [16]. Anyway, most research efforts have been focused on the
introduction of haptic feedback, intended as tactile- and/or force-
feedback, and many papers have been devoted to the distinction
between haptic, tactile and force feedback [8]. Kitagawa et al. pro-
vide a clear classification in [9] and then investigate differences in
forces applied while performing knot tying exercises. Other studies
focused on the evaluation of surgeon performance during the inter-
action with stiff objects [17]. Nevertheless, up to now, few studies
have been focused on the role of force feedback in the manipula-
tion of soft tissues. One of these was done by Wagner et al. in [19].
He observed that, in blunt dissection, the absence of force feedback
increased the magnitude of forces applied to the tissue and also the
number of errors that could damage the tissue.
Our approach is as well focused on force feedback: prelimi-
nary work on force sensing micro instruments is presented in [14]
and [13]. Because of size and limited spatial resolution of tactile
sensors, tactile feedback has, as a matter of fact, severe limita-
tions, mainly imposed by technological constraints [10]. Moreover,
applications in MIS require small overall size of the sensorized
tools. The main goal of recent systems for MIS (but also for macro
and open surgery) is, in most cases, to implement teleoperation
schemes. Such systems typically consist in two slave manipula-
tors in the operating subsystem, and a complete remote workstation
with master manipulators, including visual, auditory and force re-
flection capabilities. This tele-surgery concept has been enhanced
and brought to a commercial stage, e.g. da Vinci system by Intuitive
Surgical, Inc. [6].
Besides “traditional” MIS (laparoscopy, arthroscopy), an emerg-
ing and interesting field of application can be found in prenatal
surgery. In a prenatal surgery scenario, characteristic forces and
dimensional ranges scale down to really small values, compared to
those common in open field surgery, and surgeons often need some
augmenting mechanisms to be aware of how strongly they are inter-
acting with the most delicate structures of the fetus. For the stated
above reasons, fetal surgery can be considered as one of the new
frontiers of MIS. In the last few years, diagnostics of congenital
pathologies in fetus is becoming established, but there are how-
ever a very few specialized centers worldwide where fetal surgical
procedures are performed. These interventions concern mostly spe-
cific pathologies, such as spina bifida and, although these are very
important from the scientific point of view in terms of future per-
spectives, to date, fetal surgery for the neural tube does not give any
chance of well-assessed clinical results. These types of intervention
are considered at high risk of abortion, and the solution, by now,
is to operate just after the birth, in the first 24 hours. As regards
congenital heart diseases, therapeutic treatments are even less ad-
vanced. Ultrasound and Doppler sonography, beginning from week
18, with final diagnosis on week 20-22, allow detecting patholo-
273
Symposium on Haptic Interfaces for
Virtual Environment and Teleoperator Systems 2006
March 25 - 26, Alexandria, Virginia, USA
1-4244-0226-3/06/$20.00 ©2006 IEEE