Textural Properties of Herby Cheese
Tulay Ozcan, Lutfiye Yilmaz-Ersan and Arzu Akpinar-Bayizit
Uludag University/Department of Food Engineering, Bursa, Turkey
Email: {tulayozcan, lutfiyey, abayizit}@uludag.edu.tr
Berrak Delikanli-Kiyak
Bursa, Turkey
Email: berrakdelikanli@gmail.com
Abstract—Herby (Otlu) cheese is a traditional cheese variety
which is manufactured broadly in the eastern and south-
eastern regions of Turkey. In this study the textural
properties of herby cheese containing various herbs sold in
the markets was determined. The textural characteristics of
traditional cheeses were different from industrial herby
cheeses, particularly depending on manufacturing practices
as well as raw milk composition, herbs, salt, etc. Traditional
herby cheese had lower sensory scores for color,
fracturability. Future studies should concentrate on the
standardization of manufacturing process and the effect of
herbs and their combination on final product properties to
improve consumer perception and acceptability.
Index Terms—Turkish Herby cheese, texture, sensory
I. INTRODUCTION
Cheese is a fermented milk product produced and
consumed all over the world that is known for centuries.
Cheese as being an excellent source of protein and
minerals such as calcium and phosphorus and essential
amino acids is an important food in human nutrition. It is
estimated that more than 1 000 types of cheeses differing
in their characteristics such as composition, functionality,
appearance and flavor are manufactured [1], [2].
Turkey is among the largest producers of cheese with
more than 100 varieties such as White pickled, Kasar,
Tulum, Mihalic, Herby, Abhazian, Circassian, Civil, and
Orgu cheese [3], [4].
Herby (Otlu) cheese, a semi-hard salty cheese, has
long been traditionally produced more than 200 years in
Eastern Anatolia Region (Van, Hakkari, Bitlis) as well as
in the provinces of Diyarbakir and Siirt of the South-East
Anatolia Region [5]-[7].
Herby cheese is produced using herbs that are endemic
to the specified regions which give the cheese its
characteristic appearance and flavor. These herbs belong
to the species of Allium, Thymus, Silene, Ferula, and
Anthriscus nemorosa, the local names of which are Sirmo,
Kekik, Siyabo, Heliz and Mendo, respectively (Table I).
Among these herbs Allium is the most widely used
species. It was reported that the use of different herbs and
their levels in production significantly affect the
Manuscript received July 28, 2016; revised September 28, 2016.
chemistry, biochemistry and sensory characteristics [5],
[8]-[11].
Herby cheese can be either ripened in brine or in
earthenware or plastic containers using dry-salting. In the
past, dry-salted cheeses were ripened underground;
however, brining is more preferred nowadays [10]-[12].
The artisanal manufacturing of herby cheese is from
whole unpasteurized ewe’s, cow’s and/or goat’s milk
without any addition of starter culture. The herbs used are
generally a mixture of the species of Allium,
Choerophyllum, Calamintha, Thymus or Ferula and used
at a rate of 0.1–1.5%. However, in industrial production,
pasteurized milk is preferred and the milk is acidified by
a mesophilic starter culture, e.g., Lactococcus lactis subsp.
lactis and L. lactis subsp. cremoris [13]-[15]. The cheese
is ripened at 7–8
o
C for 90–150 days; but there are no
specific national standards for the ripening time [6].
As herby cheese is preserved either dry or in brine,
there are differences in structure and appearance. It is
rindless, white colored, medium to hard consistency and
close-textured with a salty and piquant flavor [15]. This
cheese has an odor imparted by the herbs that are added
to it and its color may vary in tones between white and
yellowish. The herbs predominate in its appearance,
which is otherwise that of common white cheese [7].
Texture represents all the rheological and structural
attributes perceptible by means of mechanical, tactile, and,
when appropriate, visual and auditory receptors of any
food matrix [16]. The factors that have impact on texture
include fat globules embedded within the protein matrix,
fat globules coated with casein micelle fragments that
interact with the surrounding casein matrix, free pools of
fat, casein matrix density, proteolysis that reduces the
casein cross-linking and water content aside with the
bond strength and density between chains of fused casein
micelles. Increasing casein bond strength and density
results in enhanced firmness of the matrix [17].
Previous studies have reported the biochemical
characterization herby cheese [6], [8], [11]-[14], [18],
however, the texture analyses have not been conducted.
Therefore, the aim of this study was to evaluate the
textural and sensorial properties herby cheeses supplied
both from traditional dairy producers and industrial dairy
plants.
23
International Journal of Food Engineering Vol. 3, No. 1, June 2017
©2017 International Journal of Food Engineering
doi: 10.18178/ijfe.3.1.23-28
Uludag University /Department of Food Engineering,