PHYSICAL REVIEW E 94, 023106 (2016)
Nonequilibrium thermohydrodynamic effects on the Rayleigh-Taylor
instability in compressible flows
Huilin Lai,
1, 2
Aiguo Xu,
1, 3, *
Guangcai Zhang,
1 , †
Yanbiao Gan,
1, 4
Yangjun Ying,
1
and Sauro Succi
5
1
National Key Laboratory of Computational Physics, Institute of Applied Physics and Computational Mathematics,
P. O. Box 8009-26, Beijing 100088, China
2
School of Mathematics and Computer Science, Fujian Normal University, Fuzhou 350007, China
3
Center for Applied Physics and Technology, MOE Key Center for High Energy Density Physics Simulations,
College of Engineering, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
4
North China Institute of Aerospace Engineering, Langfang 065000, China
5
Istituto Applicazioni Calcolo, CNR, Viale del Policlinico 137, 00161 Roma, Italy
(Received 26 November 2015; revised manuscript received 6 July 2016; published 12 August 2016)
The effects of compressibility on Rayleigh-Taylor instability (RTI) are investigated by inspecting the interplay
between thermodynamic and hydrodynamic nonequilibrium phenomena (TNE, HNE, respectively) via a discrete
Boltzmann model. Two effective approaches are presented, one tracking the evolution of the local TNE effects
and the other focusing on the evolution of the mean temperature of the fluid, to track the complex interfaces
separating the bubble and the spike regions of the flow. It is found that both the compressibility effects and the
global TNE intensity show opposite trends in the initial and the later stages of the RTI. Compressibility delays the
initial stage of RTI and accelerates the later stage. Meanwhile, the TNE characteristics are generally enhanced by
the compressibility, especially in the later stage. The global or mean thermodynamic nonequilibrium indicators
provide physical criteria to discriminate between the two stages of the RTI.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.94.023106
I. INTRODUCTION
Rayleigh-Taylor instability (RTI) occurs at the interface
between two fluids with different densities, subjected to an ac-
celeration directed from the bottom density fluid to the higher
density one. A typical case is a heavy fluid resting on the top
of a lighter one in the presence of a gravitational field. Under
such conditions, density perturbations at the interface grow in
time under the effect of gravity. The first detailed study of this
instability was conducted by Rayleigh [1] in the 1880s. Later
the first study was extended to accelerated fluids by Taylor [2]
in 1950. The first experiment was performed by Lewis in
the evolution of an unstable air-water interface [3]. Another
experiment by Emmons et al. confirmed these findings [4].
Such an instability plays a prominent role in many natural and
industrial processes, such as devices for sustainable energy
production, say turbines [5], and inertial-confinement fusion
(ICF) [6], type-la supernovae [7], hot-wire diagnostics [8],
quantum magnetized plasmas [9], colloidal mixtures [10], etc.
In the above-mentioned fields, the compressibility effects
on RTI are essential and even dominate [11–14], deserving
careful investigation. In fact, many theoretical and numerical
studies have been performed, especially on the initial linear
stage [15–21]. In those studies, the compressibility effects
on RTI growth rate are generally probed via changing the
ratio of specific heats and the equilibrium pressure at the
interface. Specifically, in 2007, Lafay et al. found that, in
the isothermal case, the stratification has a stabilizing effect
while the compressibility has a destabilizing effect for two mis-
cible, viscous and compressible fluids [18]. In 2008, He et al.
reported that, in an inviscid case, the influences of the ratio of
*
Corresponding author: Xu_Aiguo@iapcm.ac.cn
†
Corresponding author: Zhang_Guangcai@iapcm.ac.cn
specific heats are as follows: the ratio mitigates the RTI when
the upper heavy fluid is more compressible, while it enhances
the RTI when the bottom fluid is more compressible [19].
In 2010, Ye et al. demonstrated that the compressibility has
destabilizing effects for inviscid compressible fluid with an
exponentially variable density profile [20].
Although the compressibility effects have been studied
extensively, several fundamental problems remain open, such
as the nonequilibrium effects in RTI, especially for the case
of increasing compressibility [21–23]. For the case with
strong compressibility, the interfacial dynamics becomes more
complicated as the RTI unfolds, resulting in very substantial
gradient forces (∇ρ ,∇u, and ∇T ) around the interfaces
and very pronounced thermodynamic nonequilibrium (TNE)
effects, where ρ , u, and T are the local density, flow velocity,
and temperature, respectively. The more pronounced the
compressibility, the more complex the interfaces and the TNE
effects as well. It is known that the Navier-Stokes model
falls short of describing the complex interfaces and TNE
effects [24–31]. At the same time, molecular dynamics and
Monte Carlo simulations cannot access macroscopic spatial-
temporal scales of interest at affordable computational cost.
Under such conditions, a kinetic approach based on a suitably
simplified model Boltzmann equation is preferable.
As a special discretization of the Boltzmann equation,
the lattice Boltzmann (LB) method has achieved great
success in various complex flows [24,25,32–42]. The LB
applications in RTI can be classified into two groups: RTI
in incompressible flows [22,23,43–52] and in compressible
flows [53–55]. In these studies, the LB method appears
as an effective numerical scheme to solve the traditional
hydrodynamic models. In recent works [25–31], the LB
method was developed to probe the trans- and supercritical
fluid behaviors or both the hydrodynamic nonequilibrium
(HNE) and TNE behaviors, which has brought some new
2470-0045/2016/94(2)/023106(11) 023106-1 ©2016 American Physical Society