PROSPECTIVE EVALUATION OF URETERAL STENT
DURABILITY IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC
URETERAL OBSTRUCTION
NEJD F. ALSIKAFI, R. COREY O’CONNOR, DIMITRI D. KUZNETSOV, ABRAHAM H. DACHMAN,
GREGORY T. BALES, AND GLENN S. GERBER
ABSTRACT
Objectives. To prospectively evaluate the durability of ureteral stents in patients with chronic ureteral
obstruction.
Methods. Twenty-nine renal units from 22 patients with known chronic ureteral obstruction treated with
indwelling ureteral stents were studied at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months after initial stent placement (7 to 8F
Percuflex) by abdominal x-ray, serum creatinine, and renal and bladder ultrasonography. Renal ultrasound
scans were performed by a single senior radiologist with specific attention paid to any increase in hydro-
nephrosis and to the presence of ureteral jets. The stent was changed when calcifications were seen along
the stent on abdominal x-ray, if an increase in serum creatinine occurred, or if any increase in hydronephrosis
or absence of ureteral jets was seen on ultrasonography. In addition, the stents were changed if new-onset
flank pain and/or pyelonephritis developed. If none of the above occurred, the stents were changed after 12
months.
Results. Two patients died of metastatic cancer, leaving 25 renal units available for follow-up. The mean and
median time to stent change were 6 months. At 3, 6, 9, and 12 months, the number of renal units that did
not meet the criteria warranting stent change was 18 (72%), 12 (48%), 6 (24%), and 2 (8%), respectively.
Only 2 (8%) of 25 renal units did not meet any exclusion criteria at 12 months. The most common reasons
for requiring the stent to be changed were new-onset flank pain in 8 (35%), an increase in serum creatinine
in 7 (30%), and new-onset or increased hydronephrosis in 7 (30%). No criteria were useful in predicting how
long stents could be maintained in an individual patient.
Conclusions. The stents were maintained for more than 6 months in 12 (48%) of 25 renal units. However,
very few patients were able to maintain chronic ureteral stents for 12 months without requiring stent change
based on our criteria. UROLOGY 59: 847–850, 2002. © 2002, Elsevier Science Inc.
P
atients with chronic hydronephrosis are often
treated with indwelling ureteral stents that are
usually changed every 3 to 6 months. The fre-
quency of stent changes is a source of patient
bother and subjects patients to an increased risk of
anesthetic and/or iatrogenic complications. Fur-
thermore, many patients endure significant dis-
comfort due to urinary tract instrumentation.
These factors undoubtedly have a negative impact
on the patient’s quality of life.
In an effort to assess the durability of recently
produced stents, human and animal studies have
been performed that suggest that ureteral stents
can remain patent and be safely left in situ for 9 to
24 months in certain subsets of patients.
1–3
How-
ever, it is unclear from these studies whether pa-
tients can withstand less frequent stent changes
without adverse consequences such as encrusta-
tion, infection, obstruction, and loss of renal func-
tion.
4,5
Additionally, calcifications can make stent
removal difficult and in some cases may necessitate
auxiliary procedures such as extracorporeal shock
wave lithotripsy or other procedures to be per-
formed.
6
It is also unclear what factors, if any, can
be used to predict reliably the frequency that stent
changes will be needed in an individual patient.
In the present study, we prospectively evaluated
From the Departments of Surgery, Section of Urology, and Radi-
ology, University of Chicago Hospitals, Chicago, Illinois
Reprint requests: Nejd F. Alsikafi, M.D., Department of Sur-
gery, Section of Urology, MC6038, University of Chicago Hospi-
tals, 5841 South Maryland Avenue, Chicago, IL 60611
Submitted: November 8, 2001, accepted (with revisions): Jan-
uary 28, 2002
ADULT UROLOGY
© 2002, ELSEVIER SCIENCE INC. 0090-4295/02/$22.00
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED PII S0090-4295(02)01599-6 847