169
Reading in a Participatory Culture, edited by Henry Jenkins, Wyn Kelley, Katie Clinton, Jenna McWilliams,
Ricardo Pitts-Wiley, and Erin Reilly. Copyright © 2013 by Teachers College, Columbia University. All rights re-
served. Prior to photocopying items for classroom use, please contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Customer
Service, 222 Rosewood Dr., Danvers, MA 01923, USA, tel. (978) 750-8400, www.copyright.com.
CHAPTER 15
Participatory Assessment in a
Climate of Accountability
Daniel Hickey, Michelle Honeyford,
and Jenna McWilliams
Test-based accountability is perhaps the biggest obstacle for teachers who
want to use tools like the Teachers’ Strategy Guide (TSG). A decade of No
Child Leſt Behind has driven many schools from such innovations. Instead,
more students face weeks of dreary preparation for tests based on long lists
of isolated concepts and basic skills, getting ready for so-called interim as-
sessments. As argued forcefully elsewhere in this volume, basic reading
and writing skills and broad-domain knowledge are crucial for success in
the digital networks that are becoming central to youth’s economic, social,
and civic lives. Unfortunately, continuing efforts to raise achievement test
scores directly don’t foster these skills and knowledge in ways that are use-
ful in networked contexts.
Meanwhile, policy makers and administrators insist that all education-
al innovations be proved to affect achievement scores in strict experimen-
tal studies. For reasons that can be surprisingly complicated, it is difficult
to obtain such evidence of success for most innovations in typical schools.
Participatory innovations like the TSG work by transforming the culture of
entire classrooms, communities, and schools. While these transformations
can and do leave behind broadly useful individual knowledge of academic
topics, they do so somewhat indirectly—a problem for traditional models
of testing and evaluation.
Fortunately, new ideas about assessment, testing, and accountability
from the learning sciences and elsewhere offer new responses to these
challenges. is chapter describes how we tapped some of these ideas