PHYSICAL REVIEW FLUIDS 5, 124609 (2020)
Effect of body shape on riblets performance
Benedetto Mele
*
and Renato Tognaccini
Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Naples Federico II, P.zzle Tecchio 80, Italy
Pietro Catalano and Donato de Rosa
CIRA Italian Aerospace Research Center, Capua (CE) 81043, Italy
(Received 1 August 2020; accepted 4 December 2020;
published 28 December 2020)
The effect of partial slip flow on airfoil performance at high Reynolds numbers is
analyzed in this paper. The link between the physical mechanism of drag reduction attained
by many devices and the slip length concept has been well assessed in the literature. A slip
length model is therefore here adopted in large eddy simulations to quantify the effect of
slip flow on airfoil performance. The possibility to adopt a slip flow boundary condition
to simulate riblets on airfoil is verified. Their effectiveness in reducing friction drag in
turbulent flow has been well assessed since the end of the last century. Both theory and
experiments proved that the effect of riblets only depends on the local Reynolds number.
However, some experiments showed an increased effectiveness of riblets in the presence of
pressure gradient. This secondary effect is still being debated and a physical explanation
has not been found. This paper has the aim to provide a contribution to the understanding
of this phenomenon. Large eddy simulations of flows around airfoils are proposed with an
extensive analysis of riblet performance, obtained by a proper slip flow boundary condition.
It is shown that riblets reduce the boundary layer displacement thickness inducing small but
significant modifications to the pressure distribution, in particular in the adverse pressure
gradient region. The reduced thickening of the equivalent body is the reason for the reduced
form drag.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevFluids.5.124609
I. INTRODUCTION
Experiments on flows over a flat plate and channel flows [1,2] showed that streamwise mi-
crogrooved surfaces (riblets) are able to reduce skin friction drag in the turbulent regime up to
8%. Theoretical studies [2,3] contributed to clarify that the involved drag reduction mechanism
can be essentially reduced to a shift U
+
of the turbulent velocity profile in the log-law region.
Experiments and available theories proved that the effect of riblets is essentially local, i.e., only
depends on the local Reynolds number [1–3].
Walsh [4] analyzed the effect of pressure gradient on riblets’ performance reporting that riblet
data for pressure gradient flows were contradictory, while Choi [5] found a negligible effect.
However, some later experiments and numerical simulations investigating flow over a flat plate
under an adverse pressure gradient showed increased effectiveness of riblets, see Debisschop and
Nieuwstadt [6] for instance with the result confirmed by large eddy simulations (LES) [7]. Other
experiments in airfoil flows [8] and wind turbine airfoils (Sareen et al. [9], Chamorro et al. [10]) also
reported an increasing efficiency of riblets with the angle of attack implying an effect of pressure
*
benmele@unina.it
2469-990X/2020/5(12)/124609(13) 124609-1 ©2020 American Physical Society