Noninvasive Ventilation Outside Critical Care Units for Children with Severe
Low Respiratory Infection: Is it a Potential Strategy for Critically Ill Children in
Uruguay?
Alicia Aleman
1*
and Gustavo Giachetto
2
1
Department of Preventive Medicine, School of Medicine, University of the Republic, Uruguay
2
Pediatric Clinic C, School of Medicine, University of the Republic, Uruguay
*Corresponding author: Alicia Aleman, Department of Preventive Medicine, School of Medicine, University of the Republic, Uruguay, Tel: +598557679; E-mail:
aaleman@unicem-web.org
Rec date: Mar 12, 2014, Acc date: Mar 12, 2014, Pub date: Mar 14, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Aleman A, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Low Respiratory Infection
Acute lower respiratory tract infection remains as one of the frst
causes of infant death in several Latin American countries [1,2]. It also
represents one of the frst causes of admission in pediatric intensive
care (ICU) units due to acute respiratory failure for developed and
developing countries [3].
Children in this situation are provided mechanical ventilatory
support and in some cases noninvasive ventilation (NIV) in a frst
stage during admission in the intensive care units [4].
Lack of pediatric intensive care resources to give response to the
high demands in winter time appears as one of the main public health
problems for the treatment of children with acute respiratory failure
due to acute lower respiratory tract infection [3].
Te study developed by Alonso et al. in 2012 has the objective to
describe the results of applying noninvasive ventilation in a non-
intensive care environment in children under two years with acute
lower respiratory tract infection and analyze potential predictors of
failure [5].
It was performed in the biggest pediatric public hospital in
Montevideo, Uruguay during 2009 and 2010. It is a descriptive study
with a prospective recruitment. Children under 2 years with lower
respiratory tract infection and respiratory failure Tal score>8, or >6
and not responding to treatment were included. Children weighing <7
kg, unstable hemodynamics, neuro-psychic depression,
pneumothorax, pneumo-mediastinum and/or mixed acidosis were
excluded. NIV was applied in an area of moderate care outside
intensive care units (combined with aspiration and administration of
bronchodilator drugs according to requirements). A continuous
monitoring of children was maintained and failure to INV was defned
if no improvement or
Clinical deterioration despite using maximum parameters (PS 12
EPAP 10 FI02>0.6), severe hypercapnia (pCO2 ≥ 60) Glasgow ≤ 8;
mechanical complications (pneumothorax, pneumomediastinum),
hemodynamic instability or pH<7.20. In all these cases mechanical
ventilatory support was applied.
NIV was successful in 151 of 185 children included (81.6%). No
statistical diferences in terms of age, weight and severity of disease at
admission were identifed between the group of children with
treatment failure or success. Afer 2 hours respiratory frequency (RF)
greater than 60 rpm, heart rate (HR) increased 140 cpm and support
pressure (SP) greater to 9 were associated with failure (p <0.05). Two
children presented pneumothorax and one died.
Multivariate analysis showed that afer 2 h the RF>60 rpm increase
the risk of failure 6.4 times (CI 95 1.9 to 21.7), HR>140 cpm 4.3 (CI95
1.5 to 11.8) and SP>9 increased 8.7 times (CI95 2.3 to 32.2). Although
increased heart rate appears as a potential predictive value it has to be
taken with caution since it is unspecifc.
We need to identify factors associated with success or failure of NIV
having a predictive behavior to make decisions in a timely manner. Te
observed relationship between elevated heart rate at admission and 2 h
with higher failure rate has limitations. Te observed diference is not
clinically signifcant and the majority of these patients receive multiple
treatments which modify heart rate and variations could also be
explained by hypoxemia and increased respiratory work. However, we
emphasize that, as observed in other studies, the severity of respiratory
work, particularly respiratory rate was an indicator of treatment failure
with a more specifc behavior [6,7].
Tis study has some methodological limitations that should be
mention. Te frst one is absence of a control group that could provide
unbiased comparisons of results. Another issue is limited sample size
what could explain the broad confdence intervals that increase
imprecision in the estimation of potential predictor factors of failure.
On the other hand, it is one of the very few studies performed in
low-middle income countries regarding this type of health problem.
Data collection was prospective avoiding limitation of retrospective
studies based in records review.
Te routine clinical application of NIV in critical lower respiratory
tract infections management outside ICU requires further study but it
appears as a promising strategy to optimize use of resource with good
results. Future research should be directed to promote multicenter
randomized clinical studies with appropriate sample sizes that could
prove the beneft of promote NIV outside ICU for selected critically ill
children.
NIV applied outside of ICU could reduce the demand for beds in
these units at the most critical period of the year and also reduce
complications associated with conventional mechanical ventilation. It
should be the frst option when possible since, according to current
evidence, success or failure can be assessed shortly (two hours afer
implementation).
However, some concerns should be addressed, mainly to assure the
accessibility to mechanic ventilation support for those children not
responding to NIV and the availability of enough trained staf able to
Aleman and Giachetto, J Neonatal Biol 2014, 3:2
DOI: 10.4172/2167-0897.1000e109
Editorial Open Access
J Neonatal Biol
ISSN:2167-0897 JNB, an open access journal
Volume 3 • Issue 2 • 1000e109
J
o
u
r
n
a
l
o
f
N
e
o
n
a
t
a
l
B
i
o
l
o
g
y
ISSN: 2167-0897
Journal of Neonatal Biology