“Mircea cel Batran” Naval Academy Scientific Bulletin, Volume XIX – 2016 – Issue 1
Published by “Mircea cel Batran” Naval Academy Press, Constanta, Romania // The journal is indexed in:
PROQUEST / DOAJ / DRJI / JOURNAL INDEX / I2OR / SCIENCE LIBRARY INDEX / Google Scholar / Crossref /
Academic Keys / ROAD Open Access / OAJI / Academic Resources / Scientific Indexing Services / SCIPIO
13
DOI: 10.21279/1454-864X-16-I1-002
© 2015. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 4.0 License.
COMMUNICATION PROBLEMS IN A MIXED CREW
ENVIRONMENT
Carmen ASTRATINEI
1
1
Assoc. Prof. PhD, Navigation and Naval Transport , „Mircea cel Batran” Naval Academy
Abstract: Shipping has become a highly international and multicultural industry due to a globalised labour
market of seafarers. About two thirds of the world`s merchant fleets, are manned by a mixed crew, which
may include two to three different nationalities. The common language used on board ship is English. So the
crewmembers must have a good command of this language. 80% of all maritime accidents are, according to
incident reports, caused by human error i.e. negligence, fatigue, incompetence or communication
breakdown. Another factor that may affect the safety of crew and cargo is the cultural differences within the
mixed nationality crews which, if not appeased in time, may lead to very serious conflicts. This paper
proposes to analyse some characteristics of the Asian culture and traditions and suggest some ways of
improving the professional relationship among multinational crew members by making them aware of their
shipmates identities. A questionnaire, which we intend to use as a research tool, will be provided and
explained.
Key words: mixed nationality crews cultural differences human element communication
Introduction
The increase in technology, the reduction in
manning scales, the employment aboard ships of
multi-national crews due to economic reasons (i.e.
fewer employees and cheaper manpower mean
important cutting down costs for shipping
companies). The employment of multicultural
crews has given rise to such issues as
communication problems which may affect the
safety of the crew and cargo. Communication is
an essential part of human interaction. In seafarer
profession misunderstandings may lead to serious
maritime incidents involving the safety of the crew
and cargo as well as the protection of the
environment. So the issue is that on board a
mixed nationality crew, where the official language
for alarms and orders is English, measures should
be taken (both by the shipping companies and by
the Master) that the crew members can account
for their competency in Maritime English, in
compliance with the STCW`98 requirements and
that the crew members nationalities are
compatible in the sense that they can work
together as a team. In order that this compatibility
should be achieved, training courses in other
cultures traditions and ways of behaviour should
be organised both for the managers and for the
crews.
The Asian Culture
We have chosen the Asian Culture because most
of the multinational crewmembers are Asians and
the shipping companies and ship masters should
have an insight into this culture so as to be able to
train their other nationality employees to know
what to do or not to do to avoid offending their
Asian mates in any way, thus ensuring an amiable
work environment. The idea goes both ways. The
Asian crew members should be trained in their
other nationality colleagues` culture and traditions
as well.
Here are some do`s and don’ts when you have
Asian colleagues. It is a synthesis of the Globe
Study of 62 Societies, Stage Publication 2004,
findings about Korean, Indian, Japanese and
Chinese cultures. Common behavioural features
for Asian people would be honesty, modesty,
punctuality, patience, loyalty, respect for the
family concept and for religious and cultural
beliefs, for relationship and trust in other people.
So in order to avoid conflicts, people of other
nationalities should not be too direct in their
conversation with their Asian mates, should not be
in any way aggressive either physically or
verbally, nor should show anger. The Asians are
obedient and know very well how to carry out
precise orders. They do not have to be shouted at
because this means aggression which
discourages and prevents them from carrying out
their duties properly.
Our point is that multicultural crews should attend
some courses on intercultural awareness so as to
be familiarised with other cultures ways and
traditions. Therefore, a coursebook should be
designed in this respect. In order to design a
coursebook you have to do some inquiry, some
quantitative and qualitative research to collect
information about the problems occurring in
multinational crews and then decide on the
solutions to avoid them.
So we have designed a questionnaire to be
addressed to seafarers of all nationalities to state