Author Proof
10.1586/ERS.12.67 1 ISSN 1747-6348 © 2012 Expert Reviews Ltd www.expert-reviews.com
Review
Definition & use of term cardiac asthma
James Hope was the first to publish the term
‘cardiac asthma’ in 1832. He distinguished
among several variants of asthma and described
the symptoms that differentiated asthma related
to diseases of the heart from those caused by
diseases of the lungs [1] . Osler, describing cardiac
asthma in 1897, wrote “In cases of advanced
arteriosclerosis there are often attacks of dysp-
nea of great intensity recurring in spasms, often
nocturnal. The patient goes to bed feeling quite
well, and in the early morning hours wakes in
an attack which in its abruptness of onset and
general features, resembles asthma” [2] . Kahn
(1927) described two distinct forms of cardiac
dyspnea. One “depends upon the stasis in the
pulmonary circulation associated with right
ventricular deficiency”, which he called pulmo-
nary asthma; the other “depends on deficiency
of the left ventricle alone, with irritability of the
respiratory center producing attacks of parox-
ysmal dyspnea or cardiac asthma” [3] . In 1951,
Lombardo and Harrison defined cardiac asthma
as a syndrome induced by acute passive conges-
tion and edema of the lungs occurring when
the left side of the heart “suffers from a sud-
den disproportion between work load and work
capacity” [4] .
These venerable descriptions of cardiac
asthma are not far removed from the current
view of cardiac asthma as wheezing, coughing
and orthopnea due to congestive heart failure
and not to primary pulmonary disease. A com-
monly held view is that it is hemodynamic in
origin and a consequence of pulmonary and
bronchial venous hypertension.
Prevalence of cardiac asthma
It has been reported that the prevalence of
all asthma in persons over the age 65 years is
between 6.5 [5] and 10.4% [6] , consistent with
the 8% prevalence among those enrolled in the
large Cardiovascular Health Study [7] . This
is also consistent with the 7.5% prevalence in
those over the age of 65 years in data from the
National Health Interview Survey, National
Center for Health Statistics, CDC [201] .
However among the elderly who have conges-
tive heart failure, wheezing consistent with the
syndrome of cardiac asthma is present in 35%
of these patients [8] . This is more than 3.5-times
greater than the reported prevalence of asthma
in the elderly. It is likely that most or all of
the excess asthma diagnoses represent cases of
cardiac asthma.
Pathophysiology of the effect of heart
failure on airways
Nocturnal attacks of coughing, wheezing and
dyspnea are common in patients with impaired
left ventricular function. While the mechanisms
responsible for this remain obscure, several
processes have been investigated that could
contribute to cardiac asthma.
Tsuyoshi Tanabe,
Henry J Rozycki,
Soichiro Kanoh and
Bruce K Rubin*
Department of Pediatrics, Virginia
Commonwealth University School of
Medicine and the Children’s Hospital of
Richmond at VCU, Richmond, VA, USA
*Author for correspondence:
Tel.: +1 804 828 9602
brubin@vcu.edu
Cardiac asthma has been defined as wheezing, coughing and orthopnea due to congestive
heart failure. The clinical distinction between bronchial asthma and cardiac asthma can be
straight forward, except in patients with chronic lung disease coexisting with left heart disease.
Pulmonary edema and pulmonary vascular congestion have been thought to be the primary
causes of cardiac asthma but most patients have a poor response to diuretics. There appears to
be limited effectiveness of classical asthma medications like bronchodilators or corticosteroids
in treating cardiac asthma. Evidence suggests that circulating inflammatory factors and tissue
growth factors also lead to airway obstruction suggesting the possibility of developing novel
therapies.
Cardiac asthma: new insights
into an old disease
Expert Rev. Respir. Med. 6(6), 00–00 (2012)
KEYWORDS: airflow obstruction • airway inflammation • heart failure • pulmonary edema • remodeling heart
• squamous metaplasia • systemic inflammation • TGF-b