1 Copyright © 2002 by ASME
Proceedings of ETCE2002
ASME Engineering Technology Conference on Energy
February 4-6, 2002, Houston, TX
ETCE 2002/MANU-29103
PERFORMANCE AND CONTROL OF LIQUID-LIQUID CYLINDRICAL CYCLONE SEPARATORS
Rajkumar Mathiravedu
REDA Production Systems, Schlumberger
Bartlesville, OK 74005
Shoubo Wang, Ram S. Mohan and Ovadia Shoham
Petroleum and Mechanical Engg. Departments
The University of Tulsa
Tulsa, OK - 74104
Jack D. Marrelli, ChevronTexaco E&P Technology Company
Houston, TX - 77082
ABSTRACT
The feasibility of using Liquid-Liquid Cylindrical Cyclone
(LLCC
1
) as a free water knockout device for bulk separation
of oil-water mixtures in the field strongly depends on the
implementation of control systems due to its compactness, less
residence time and possible inlet flow variations. In this
investigation, the LLCC control dynamics have been studied
extensively both theoretically and experimentally. A linear
model has been developed for the first time for LLCC
separators equipped with underflow watercut control, which
enables simulation of the system dynamic behavior. A unique
“direct” control strategy is developed and implemented, capable
of obtaining clear water in the underflow line and maintaining
maximum underflow rate. Dedicated control system simulations
are conducted using Matlab/Simulink
â
software to simulate the
real system dynamic behavior. Detailed experimental
investigations are conducted to evaluate the system sensitivity
and dynamic behavior of the proposed control strategy. The
results demonstrate that the proposed control system is capable
of controlling the underflow watercut around its set point by
obtaining maximum free-water knockout for a wide range of
flow conditions. (inlet water concentration of 40% and an inlet
mixture velocity of 1.5 m/s).
INTRODUCTION
The production of water with oil continues to be a problem for
the oil industry. Oil and gas companies are constantly searching
1
LLCC - Liquid-Liquid Cylindrical Cyclone - Copyright, The University of
Tulsa, 1998.
2
GLCC - Gas-Liquid Cylindrical Cyclone - Copyright, The University of
Tulsa, 1994.
for more effective ways to handle produced water and to
increase oil production. Since 1865, when water was co-
produced with hydrocarbons, it has challenged and frustrated
the industry on how to separate the valuable hydrocarbon (oil)
from the disposable (water). Innovations over the years have
led from the skim pit to installation of the stock tank, to the gun
barrel, to the free water knockout device and most recently to
compact separators. Compact separators such as Gas-Liquid
Cylindrical Cyclone (GLCC
©2
) and Liquid-Liquid Cylindrical
Cyclone hold a key element in reducing the costs of production
operation. These separators are simple, compact, low-cost,
require little maintenance and are easy to install and operate.
GLCCs that have already been installed and put to use in the
field have demonstrated the pronounced impact that this
technology is bound to have on the petroleum industry. Most of
the studies have been carried out for gas-liquid separation. To
further enhance the applicability of cylindrical cyclone, the
technology is extended to design LLCC for oil-water separation.
A schematic of the LLCC separator is shown in Figure 1.
The LLCC is a vertically installed pipe mounted with a
horizontal inlet pipe. The oil-water mixture is introduced
through a tangential slot at the inlet. It has two exits, the upper
outlet that is oil rich stream, and the lower outlet, that is clear
water stream. It has neither moving parts nor internal devices.
Separation occurs due to the centrifugal forces caused by the
swirling motion and the gravity forces. The heavier water is
forced radially towards the cyclone wall and is collected from
the bottom, while the lighter oil moves towards the center of the
cyclone and is taken out from the top. Thus, it provides an
efficient alternative for oil-water separation as a free water
knockout device.
The performance of LLCC strongly depends upon the split
of oil rich and clear water streams. Thus, the control system