Control of Non-linear Marine Cooling System
Michael Hansen, Jakob Stoustrup, Jan Dimon Bendtsen
Abstract— We consider the problem of designing control
laws for a marine cooling system used for cooling the main
engine and auxiliary components aboard several classes of
container vessels. We focus on achieving simple set point
control for the system and do not consider compensation of the
non-linearities, closed circuit flow dynamics or transport delays
that are present in the system. Control laws are therefore
designed using classical control theory and the performance of
the design is illustrated through a simulation example where
it is compared to a reference control design.
I. INTRODUCTION
In recent years the attention to energy efficiency in the
shipping industry has increased as a consequence of fluctuat-
ing oil prices [1] and a growing focus on CO
2
, NO
x
and SO
x
emissions from maritime transportation [2]. This has led to
several initiatives within the shipping industry to bring down
the energy consumption in ocean-going vessels, ranging
from waste heat recovery systems to energy optimization of
subsystems [3].
In this paper we consider design of control laws for a
cooling system found aboard several classes of ocean-going
container vessels. The system in question is used for cooling
the main engine and auxiliary components and currently
makes use of a very simple control method. In the current
control, the pumps in the cooling system are operated in
three steps based on the temperature of the sea water and
the load on the main engine [4]. The result is that the
pumps in this type of cooling system are used excessively,
and that operating conditions are unlikely to be optimal
in particular for the main engine auxiliary components.
This leaves a significant potential for energy savings by
improving the existing controls, not only by lowering the
power consumption of the pumps, but also by ensuring
optimal operating conditions for the main engine auxiliary
components and thereby improving their energy efficiency.
The focus in this paper is on the latter, which means that
the control design aims at achieving the desired set point
temperatures for main engine auxiliary components, rather
than achieving optimal energy efficiency for the pumps.
A model for the cooling system was derived in [5] and
is adopted here for the control design and for simulating
M. Hansen is with A.P. Moeller - Maersk A/S, MMT - Innovation,
Esplanaden 50, DK-1098, Copenhagen, Denmark and is also affiliated with
the Department of Electronic Systems, Section for Automation and Control,
Aalborg University, Fredrik Bajers Vej 7, DK-9320, Aalborg, Denmark (e-
mail: michael.hansen1@maersk.com).
Jakob Stoustrup and Jan Dimon Bendtsen are with the Department of
Electronic Systems, Section for Automation and Control, Aalborg Univer-
sity, Fredrik Bajers Vej 7, DK-9320, Aalborg, Denmark (e-mail: {jakob,
dimon}@es.aau.dk)
the compensated system. The control laws derived in this
paper serves the purpose of improving the performance of
the cooling system compared to the current control method.
The remainder of the paper is structured as follows: In
Section II we give a short description of the system and
present the model. In Section III we present the control
strategy and derive control laws for the system. Section
IV presents simulation results for the control design and
conclusions are given in Section V.
II. MODEL
The cooling system consists of three circuits; a sea water
(SW) circuit, a low temperature (LT) circuit and a high
temperature (HT) circuit. This is illustrated in Fig. 1 where
q
LT
and q
SW
are volumetric flows in the LT and SW circuits,
while q
HT
is the volumetric flow to the HT circuit.
Central coolers
Sea water
circuit
Low temperature
components
Main engine
Low temperature
circuit
High temperature
circuit
TT
TT
q
LT
q
SW
q
HT
Fig. 1. Simplified system layout.
The SW circuit pumps sea water through the cold side
of the central coolers for lowering the temperature of the
coolant in the LT and HT circuits. The HT circuit only
contains the main engine of the ship, while the LT circuit
contains all the main engine auxiliary components in a
parallel configuration. In the current control scheme, the
SW circuit pumps are operated in three steps depending on
the temperature of the sea water and the operating mode
of the vessel. This setup is designed such that the SW
circuit provides sufficient cooling, even when the sea water
temperature is high, which means that under most operating
conditions the SW circuit generates excess cooling. Similar
to the SW pumps, the LT pumps are also controlled in
2011 IEEE International Conference on Control Applications (CCA)
Part of 2011 IEEE Multi-Conference on Systems and Control
Denver, CO, USA. September 28-30, 2011
978-1-4577-1063-6/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE 88