Voluntary intake and digestibility of reed canarygrass
and timothy hay fed to horses
1
A. L. Ordakowski-Burk,*
2
R. W. Quinn,* T. A. Shellem,* and L. R. Vough†
Departments of *Animal and Avian Sciences and †Natural Resource Sciences and Landscape Architecture,
University of Maryland, College Park 20742
ABSTRACT: Thousands of hectares of timothy
(Phleum pretense L.) grown in the Mid-Atlantic region
are infected by cereal rust mite (Abacarus hysterix) that
causes discoloration and curling of leaves, decreased
nutritional quality, and substantial decreases in yield.
A decline in production of timothy hay can lower income
for hay producers and cause horse owners to search for
alternative hays. Low alkaloid reed canarygrass (Pha-
laris arundinacea L.) hay has potential as an alterna-
tive to timothy hay because it grows well in the Mid-
Atlantic region, is believed to have a similar nutrient
quality to timothy, and is not as susceptible to cereal
rust mite. Eleven mature, stalled Thoroughbred geld-
ings (549 ± 12.1 kg) that were exercised daily were used
to compare voluntary DMI and apparent nutrient DM
digestibility of timothy and low-alkaloid Chiefton vari-
ety reed canarygrass hay. Horses were paired by age
and BW and randomly assigned to timothy or reed ca-
narygrass hay during a 14-d period to measure volun-
tary DMI followed by a 4-d period to measure apparent
DM digestibility. Both hays met the minimum require-
Key words: digestibility, hay, horse, reed canarygrass, timothy, voluntary intake
©2006 American Society of Animal Science. All rights reserved. J. Anim. Sci. 2006. 84:3104–3109
doi:10.2527/jas.2005-607
INTRODUCTION
Timothy hay is produced on an estimated 34,400 ha
in Maryland and is one of the most popular hay species
fed to horses in the Mid-Atlantic region of the United
States. However, since the late 1980s, cereal rust mite
has been infecting timothy in the Mid-Atlantic region,
causing discoloration and curling of leaves, decreased
nutritional quality, decreased yields up to 70% (Cham-
1
This research was supported in part by a grant from the Maryland
Horse Industry Board. The authors thank the staff at the Central
Maryland Research and Education Center for their assistance during
the study and Larry Douglass for assistance with statistical analysis.
2
Corresponding author: amyburk@umd.edu
Received October 20, 2005.
Accepted May 10, 2006.
3104
ments for DE, CP, Ca, P, K, Fe, and Mn, but they did
not meet the minimum requirements for Cu, Zn, and
Na for horses at maintenance and averaging 550 kg of
BW. Timothy hay seemed to have a lower CP concentra-
tion (14.4%) compared with reed canarygrass hay
(17.1%) and a more desirable Ca:P ratio at 1.6:1 com-
pared with 0.8:1 for reed canarygrass hay. Horses fed
timothy consumed more hay (P < 0.001) during the
voluntary DMI period compared with horses fed reed
canarygrass. Greater voluntary DMI of timothy oc-
curred on d 1, 3, and 5 (P < 0.05), but DMI was similar
for other days. Apparent DM digestibility was greater
in horses fed timothy hay by 9.6% compared with horses
fed reed canarygrass hay (P < 0.05). Horses fed timothy
had greater DM digestibility of ADF (P = 0.001), NDF
(P = 0.001), sugar (P = 0.05), and Ca (P = 0.001) but
lower apparent DM digestibility of CP (P = 0.012) and
crude fat (P = 0.004). Timothy hay was superior in
voluntary DMI and apparent DM digestibility com-
pared with low-alkaloid reed canarygrass hay fed to
horses.
berlain et al., 2003), and a decrease in the income of
timothy hay producers. Use of pesticides (e.g., carbaryl)
and management techniques including late-fall harvest
have decreased the impact of the cereal rust mite; how-
ever, resistance to carbaryl is expected to eventually
develop. A decline in the production of timothy hay may
cause hay producers to grow other forages adapted to
the climate of the Mid-Atlantic region, forcing horse
owners to find other suitable forage alternatives.
Reed canarygrass shows potential as an alternative
hay to timothy hay because it is a tall, leafy, high yield-
ing cool-season perennial grass that grows well in the
moist temperate climate and soils of the Mid-Atlantic
region, is tolerant to flooding and drought, and has
the potential for more summer regrowth (Balasko and
Nelson, 2003). Also, newer varieties of reed canarygrass
were shown to have equivalent or greater nutrient di-
Published December 8, 2014