* Corresponding author:
Daniel C. Rosenfeld
email: rosenfeld@energieinstitut-linz.at
Detritus / Volume 16 - 2021 / pages 106-120
https://doi.org/10.31025/2611-4135/2021.15121
© 2021 Cisa Publisher. Open access article under CC BY-NC-ND license
POTENTIALS AND COSTS OF VARIOUS RENEWABLE GASES: A
CASE STUDY FOR THE AUSTRIAN ENERGY SYSTEM BY 2050
Daniel C. Rosenfeld *, Johannes Lindorfer, Hans Böhm, Andreas Zauner and Karin
Fazeni-Fraisl
Energieinstitut an der Johannes Kepler Universität Linz, Altenberger Straße 69, 4040 Linz, Austria
Article Info:
Received:
24 March 2021
Revised:
3 August 2021
Accepted:
23 August 2021
Available online:
30 September 2021
Keywords:
Anaerobic digestion
Power-to-gas
Gas greening
Biomass gasifcation
Technoeconomic analysis
ABSTRACT
This analysis estimates the technically available potentials of renewable gases
from anaerobic conversion and biomass gasifcation of organic waste materials, as
well as power-to-gas (H2 and synthetic natural gas based on renewable electricity)
for Austria, as well as their approximate energy production costs. Furthermore, it
outlines a theoretical expansion scenario for plant erection aimed at fully using all
technical potentials by 2050. The overall result, illustrated as a theoretical merit or-
der, is a ranking of technologies and resources by their potential and cost, starting
with the least expensive and ending with the most expensive. The fndings point to
a renewable methane potential of about 58 TWh per year by 2050. The highest po-
tential originates from biomass gasifcation (~49 TWh per year), while anaerobic
digestion (~6 TWh per year) and the power-to-gas of green CO2 from biogas upgrad-
ing (~3 TWh per year) demonstrate a much lower technical potential. To fully use
these potentials, 870 biomass gasifcation plants, 259 anaerobic digesters, and 163
power-to-gas plants to be built by 2050 in the full expansion scenario. From the cost
perspective, all technologies are expected to experience decreasing specifc energy
costs in the expansion scenario. This cost decrease is not signifcant for biomass
gasifcation, at only about 0.1 €-cent/kWh, resulting in a cost range between 10.7 and
9.0 €-cent/kWh depending on the year and fuel. However, for anaerobic digestion,
the cost decrease is signifcant, with a reduction from 7.9 to 5.6 €-cent/kWh. It is
even more signifcant for power-to-gas, with a reduction from 10.8 to 5.1 €-cent/kWh
between 2030 and 2050.
1. INTRODUCTION
The major challenge of this century is climate change.
To tackle this challenge, it is necessary to fnd measures
to limit the temperature rise to a maximum of 2°C, or even
1.5°C in an optimal case (Gao et al., 2017). Therefore, it
is necessary to signifcantly reduce global CO
2
emissions
and reach, at a minimum, carbon neutrality within the next
20 to 30 years.
On a European scale, in 2011, the European Union pub-
lished a “roadmap for moving to a competitive low-carbon
economy in 2050.” This roadmap aims for a greenhouse
gas emission reduction of 80% to 95% by 2050 (European
Commission, 2011). In 2019, the European Union published
“new green deal” priority energy effciency measures. How-
ever, these measures further include the substitution of
72% of current fossil-based energy by renewable energy
since this amount cannot be reduced by effciency meas-
ures (European Commission, 2019). This goal could be
reached by either electrifcation using renewable electricity
or substitution with a renewable alternative such as fossil
natural gas with synthetic natural gas (SNG). This action
plans to reach net carbon neutrality by 2050 are mainly be-
ing carried out on a national basis.
The objective of the current program of the Austrian
Federal Government is to provide 100% of Austria's elec-
tricity supply from renewable energy sources by 2030.
Doing so requires an increase in renewable electricity gen-
eration of 27 TWh in total (11 TWh photovoltaic, 10 TWh
wind power, 5 TWh hydropower, and 1 TWh biomass). Re-
garding gas supply, an expansion and support program is
planned to promote the production of renewable gas (i.e.,
biomethane, green hydrogen, and SNG based on renewable
electricity) by 2030. The aim is to feed 5 TWh of "green gas"
into the natural gas grid by 2030. A full decarbonization of
the Austrian economy, aiming for carbon neutrality, should
be reached by 2040 (Republik Österreich, 2020). Therefore,
the Austrian natural gas demand – 87.2 TWh in 2018 (Brit-
ish Petroleum p.l.c, 2019) – must be reduced and fully sub-
stituted by renewables.