Pim A. de Jong, MSc
Mark D. Ottink, MD
Simon G. F. Robben, MD, PhD
Maarten H. Lequin, MD, PhD
Wim C. J. Hop, PhD
Johan J. E. Hendriks, MD, PhD
Peter D. Pare ´, MD
Harm A. W. M. Tiddens, MD,
PhD
Index terms:
Computed tomography (CT), in infants
and children, 60.1211, 60.12118
Computed tomography (CT), thin-
section, 60.12118
Fibrosis, cystic, 60.252
Lung, CT, 60.1211, 60.12118
Lung, function
Published online before print
10.1148/radiol.2312021393
Radiology 2004; 231:434 – 439
Abbreviations:
FEF
25%–75%
= forced expiratory flow
between 25% and 75% of
expiratory vital capacity
FEV
1
= forced expiratory volume in 1
second
FVC = forced vital capacity
PFT = pulmonary function test
Raw = airway resistance
RV = residual volume
TLC = total lung capacity
1
From the Depts of Paediatric Pulmonology
(P.A.d.J., H.A.W.M.T.) and Paediatric Radiol-
ogy (M.H.L.), Erasmus Med Ctr Rotterdam,
Sophia Children’s Hosp, Dr Molewaterplein
60, 3015 GJ Rotterdam, the Netherlands;
Dept of Epidemiology and Biostatistics
(W.C.J.H.), Erasmus Med Ctr Rotterdam, the
Netherlands; Depts of Paediatric Pulmonology
(M.D.O., J.J.E.H.) and Radiology (S.G.F.R.),
Univ Hosp Maastricht, the Netherlands; and
Univ of British Columbia, McDonald Research
Lab and iCAPTURE Ctr, St Paul’s Hosp, Van-
couver, Canada (P.D.P.). Received Oct 29,
2002; revision requested Jan 9, 2003; final
revision received Sep 10; accepted Sep 29.
Address correspondence to H.A.W.M.T.
(e-mail: h.tiddens@erasmusmc.nl ).
See also the editorial by Brody in this issue.
Author contributions:
Guarantors of integrity of entire study,
P.A.d.J., H.A.W.M.T.; study concepts and de-
sign, P.A.d.J., M.H.L., S.G.F.R., W.C.J.H.,
H.A.W.M.T.; literature research, P.A.d.J.,
H.A.W.M.T.; clinical studies, H.A.W.M.T.,
S.G.F.R., M.H.L.; data acquisition, P.A.d.J.,
M.D.O., S.G.F.R.; data analysis/interpreta-
tion, P.A.d.J., M.D.O., J.J.E.H., S.G.F.R.,
H.A.W.M.T., W.C.J.H., P.D.P.; statistical anal-
ysis, P.A.d.J., M.D.O., H.A.W.M.T., W.C.J.H.;
manuscript preparation, P.A.d.J., M.D.O.,
J.J.E.H., H.A.W.M.T.; manuscript definition of
intellectual content, P.D.P., H.A.W.M.T.,
P.A.d.J.; manuscript editing, H.A.W.M.T.,
J.J.E.H., P.A.d.J., P.D.P., M.H.L., S.G.F.R.,
M.D.O.; manuscript revision/review and final
version approval, all authors
©
RSNA, 2004
Pulmonary Disease Assessment
in Cystic Fibrosis: Comparison
of CT Scoring Systems and
Value of Bronchial and
Arterial Dimension
Measurements
1
PURPOSE: To retrospectively compare thin-section computed tomographic (CT)
scores obtained with five scoring systems for assessment of pulmonary disease in
children with cystic fibrosis and to determine additional value of bronchial and
arterial dimension measurements.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Scores obtained with five thin-section CT scoring
systems were compared. A score of 0 indicated the absence of abnormalities; a
higher score meant that more structural abnormalities were seen. Three observers
assigned scores and then reassigned scores after intervals varying from 1–2 weeks to
1–2 months at review of thin-section CT scans obtained in 25 children with cystic
fibrosis. Interobserver and intraobserver reliability was calculated with intraclass
correlation coefficients. Quantitative measurements of bronchial and arterial dimen-
sions were obtained. Thin-section CT scores were correlated (Spearman correlation)
with bronchial and arterial dimensions and with results of pulmonary function tests
(PFTs), such as forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV
1
).
RESULTS: Scores with all five scoring systems were reproducible, with intraclass
correlation coefficients of 0.74 and higher (P .05), and showed significant
correlations with FEV
1
(R =-0.73 to -0.69, P .01). Ratio of bronchial diameter
to accompanying pulmonary arterial diameter was correlated with thin-section CT
scores but not with FEV
1
. Ratio of bronchial wall thickness to accompanying pul-
monary arterial diameter was not correlated with thin-section CT scores or PFT
results.
CONCLUSION: Thin-section CT scores were reproducible and were correlated with
PFT results. Measurements of bronchial dimensions were not significantly related to
scores or PFT results.
©
RSNA, 2004
Cystic fibrosis is the most frequently inherited autosomal recessive disease in whites, with
an incidence of one in 3,600 in the Dutch population. Cystic fibrosis is a lethal disease;
when it was described by Fanconi (1) and Andersen (2) more than 60 years ago, the median
survival was less than 1 year. Presently, median survival is 32.3 years and is increasing (3).
Despite increased longevity, pulmonary dysfunction causes major morbidity in cystic
fibrosis, and more than 90% of the mortality is caused by pulmonary complications (4). It
is therefore critically important to monitor progression of lung disease for clinical treat-
ment and to evaluate new treatments. The standard for assessment of lung disease in cystic
fibrosis is pulmonary function tests (PFTs); however, conventional PFTs are not very
sensitive in the detection of early lung damage (5). In addition, the conventional PFTs are
reliable only in children older than 5 years. There is evidence that pulmonary disease starts
434
R
adiology