THE SCUFFING RESISTANCE OF THE COATED TRIBOSYSTEMS
LUBRICATED WITH ECOLOGICAL OILS
Remigiusz Michalczewski, Marian Szczerek, Waldemar Tuszynski, Jan Wulczynski
Tribology Department
Institute for Terotechnology (ITeE)
Radom, Poland
ABSTRACT
The objective of the paper is to show that thin, hard
coatings deposited on heavy-loaded machine components
working in a non-conformal contact (e.g. gears) and lubricated
with ecological oils, make it possible to increase the service-life
of these components.
The scuffing resistance was assessed by employing a high-
resolution four-ball test method realized in a tester with
continuously increasing load. Also another test method - FZG
scuffing test - was realized using a back-to-back gear test rig.
The test balls and gears were coated with thin, hard TiN and
WC/C coatings deposited using arc-vacuum and reactive
sputtering techniques respectively.
The performed tests indicate that the presence of thin
coatings on machine components gives a possibility of
eliminating or reducing the content of toxic AW/EP additives in
lubricating oils, as well as using ecological oils made of
renewable resources, without any risk of a scuffing failure.
INTRODUCTION
Increasing attention to the environmental issues and more
restrictive environmental regulations drive the lubricant
industry to increase the ecological friendliness of its products,
this means eliminating or drastically limiting the content of
AW/EP additives. However, the elimination of lubricating
additives from the oils implies that they may show poor
performance under extreme-pressure conditions, which
radically reduces the area of their application. So, the authors
postulate a new concept: taking over the function of
lubricating additives by thin, hard coatings deposited on
sliding elements, and through this promote the application of
lubricants without environmentally hazardous additives.
EXPERIMENTAL
Coatings with thickness about 2 μm were deposited by the
PVD techniques: TiN (arc-vacuum method) and WC/C
(reactive sputtering method).
A four-ball tribotester working in a sliding contact (Fig. 1)
was used for the basic experiments.
Figure 1. Four-ball sliding tribosystem.
The scuffing resistance was characterized by the so-called
limiting pressure of seizure (p
oz
). This measure is determined
according to a test method described in detail in [1]. The higher
p
oz
value, the better action of the tested lubricant under extreme
pressure conditions.
The results were verified using a back-to-back gear test rig
of FZG type (Fig. 2) where the resistance to scuffing for
lubricated test gears was investigated.
Figure 2. Test tribosystem of the gear test rig.
1 Copyright © 2005 by ASME
Proceedings of WTC2005
World Tribology Congress III
September 12-16, 2005, Washington, D.C., USA
WTC2005-63432