Plant and Soil 152: 131-138, 1993.
© 1993 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands. PLSO BNF14
Minimizing the effect of mineral nitrogen on biological nitrogen fixation
in common bean by increasing nutrient levels
S.M. TSAI l, R. BONETTI 1, S.M. AGBALA 2 and R. ROSSETI'O 1
~Centro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura, University of S~o Paulo, Caixa P.O. Box 96, Piracicaba
CEP 13400-970, S~o Paulo, Brazil; 2Commissariat GOnOral ~ L'Energie Atomique, Kinsasha, Zaire
Key words: bean, 15N isotope, nitrogen fixation, N fertilizer, phosphorus, potassium, Rhizobium
tropici, sulphur
Abstract
Although common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) has good potential for N 2 fixation, some additional N
provided through fertilizer usually is required for a maximum yield. In this study the suppressive effect
of N on nodulation and N 2 fixation was evaluated in an unfertile soil under greenhouse conditions with
different levels of soil fertility (low = no P, K and S additions; medium = 50, 63 and 10 mg kg -~ soil and
high = 200, 256 and 40 mgkg -1 soil, respectively) and combined with 5, 15, 60 and 120mgN kg -1 soil
of ~SN-labelled urea. The overall average nodule number and weight increased under high fertility
levels. At low N applications, nitrogen had a synergistic effect on N 2 fixation, by stimulating nodule
formation, nitrogenase activity and plant growth. At high fertility and at the highest N rate
(120 mg kg -1 soil), the stimulatory effect of N fertilizer on N 2 fixation was still observed, increasing the
amounts of N 2 fixed from 88 up to 375 mg N plant -1. These results indicate that a suitable balance of
soil nutrients is essential to obtain high N 2 fixation rates and yield in common beans.
Introduction
Common bean is capable of fixing large amounts
of atmospheric N 2 under certain conditions, but
usually some mineral N is needed to achieve
substantial yields under the prevailing cropping
system in Latin America. However, nitrogen
fertilization affects nodulation of bean plants and
therefore the usually-recommended rates of 40-
60kgNha i suppress N 2 fixation (Ruschel et
al., 1979a; Graham, 1981). On the other hand,
low rates have been shown to enhance nodule
formation and function but are not sufficient to
achieve maximum yields (Sistachs, 1970; Rosas
and Bliss, 1987). While it is known that bean
plants require high levels of P, K, S, Ca, Mg,
Mo, Co and B (Bonetti et al., 1984; Franco and
Day, 1980; Ruschel and Reuszer, 1973; Saito
and Ruschel, 1978), production is restricted
mostly to marginal soils where sufficient nutri-
ents are not available. In soybean and tropical
legumes, nodulation is especially sensitive to
non-optimal levels of combined nutrients (Cass-
man et al., 1981; Franqa et al., 1973; Gates and
Wilson, 1974; Hernandez and Focht, 1985; Lynd
and Ansman, 1989, 1990).
Gates and Muller (1979) observed that nodu-
lation in soybean is affected by unbalanced
nutritional conditions of N, P and S, and that N 2
fixation was not affected by mineral N only in
presence of high levels of P and S. Lynd and
Ansman (1989) found decreases in nodule
number of peanut when K was applied alone,
but not when P and Ca were added. A stimulat-
ory effect of the high rate of 60mgkg -~ of
NH4NO 3 on nodulation also has been reported
in presence of P (Gates and Wilson, 1974).
This study was performed to determine
whether applied nitrogen affects nodulation and
plant biomass under limited and balanced soil