An Investigation into Neurologic and Neurobehavioral Effects of
Long-Term Agrichemical Use among Deciduous Fruit Farm Workers
in the Western Cape, South Africa
1,2
L. London,* J. E. Myers,* V. Nell,† T. Taylor,‡ and M. L. Thompson§
*Occupational Health Research Unit, Department of Community Health, and §Department of Statistical Sciences, University of Cape
Town, Cape Town, South Africa; †Health Psychology Unit, University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa; and ‡Human Sciences
Research Council, Johannesburg, South Africa
Received March 5, 1996
Long-term exposure to organophosphates (OPs)
in the absence of acute poisoning is increasingly
suspected of causing chronic neurologic and neuro-
behavioral effects. A cross-sectional survey of 163
spray operators on deciduous fruit farms in the
Western Cape, South Africa, and 84 nonspraying
labororers was conducted in 1993 to investigate the
relationship between long-term OP exposures and
neurological and neurobehavioral outcomes. The
study also sought to evaluate the performance of a
set of neurobehavioral test batteries based on the
information-processing theory of cognitive psychol-
ogy, relative to the more established World Health
Organization’s Neurobehavioral Core Test Battery
(WHO NCTB). These information-processing tests
were designed for use in studies of subjects with
little education, which are frequently conducted in
developing countries in agriculture. They draw on
experience from a previous South African study in
which problems were encountered with a lack of
cross-cultural validity of conventional test batter-
ies. No evidence was found of a relationship be-
tween long-term OP exposure and loss of vibration
sense. Small associations were found with the
NCTB Pursuit-Aiming and Santa Ana (nondominant
hand) subtests. The overall evidence of neurologic
and neurobehavioral effects of long-term OP expo-
sure was small; exposure misclassification may
have contributed to this finding. Important con-
founders such as brain injury, alcohol consumption,
and nutritional status were identified. © 1997 Academic
Press
INTRODUCTION
Increasingly, agrichemical exposure has been rec-
ognized as a possible cause of adverse, chronic, hu-
man health effects, particularly related to central
nervous system function (Savage et al., 1988; U.S.
Office of Technology Assessment, 1990; Davies,
1990a; Rosenstock et al., 1991). For example, it has
been shown that a number of organophosphates
(OPs) can cause a delayed peripheral neuropathy in
survivors of acute poisoning (Hierons and Johnson,
1978; Senanyake and Johnson, 1982; Vasilescu et
al., 1984; Lotti, 1992). Adverse, chronic, central ner-
vous system effects also might be detected in sub-
jects years after acute OP poisoning (Savage et al.,
1988; Rosenstock et al., 1991).
However, much of this evidence stems from stud-
ies about the effects of acute intoxication (that is,
short-term, high-dose exposures). Few data exist on
the chronic effects of long-term, low-dose agrichemi-
cal exposures in the absence of acute poisoning.
Such data would have substantial public health im-
1
This study was supported by research grants from the Inter-
national Development Research Centre (IDRC-Canada), the
South African Medical Research Council, the Ernst and Ethel
Erikson Trust, and the Guy Elliot Research Fellowship in the
Department of Medicine at the University of Cape Town.
2
This study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration
of Helsinki of the 25th World Medical Assembly and the guide-
lines established by the South African Medical Research Council.
Ethical approval for the protocol was obtained from the Ethics
and Research Committee of the University of Cape Town. All
workers who participated in the study did so on the basis of in-
formed consent, given in writing after full explanation of the pur-
pose and methods of the investigation. Consent was transacted in
Afrikaans, the first language of the subjects. Full confidentiality
was observed for the subjects. Only when appropriate (for ex-
ample, if blood chemistry was found to be low) were the usual
medical attendants of the workers informed of the need for re-
testing or for withdrawal from any additional pesticide exposure.
Follow-up of affected workers was provided through tertiary hos-
pital facilities.
ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH 73, 132–145 (1997)
ARTICLE NO. ER973715
132
0013-9351/97 $25.00
Copyright © 1997 by Academic Press
All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.