Economic Analysis of a Controllable Device with
Smart Grid Features Applied to LED Street Lighting
System
Milena F. Pinto, Thiago R. F. Mendonça, Fabricio Coelho and Henrique A. C. Braga
Federal University of Juiz de Fora – UFJF
Juiz de Fora, MG – Brazil
milena.faria@engenharia.ufjf.br
Abstract—Almost all luminaires that are used in street
lighting system does not have communication, control and
management infrastructure. Moreover, the artificial lighting
system is responsible for the consumption of approximately 30%
of all electricity generated in the world. Within this context, the
LED technology offers flexibility and high efficiency, being
suitable to be connected with smart devices, allowing the usage of
possible alternatives to reduce energy consumption and
providing significant economic saving. This work aims to
perform an economic analysis of a controllable device with smart
grid features applied to LED street lighting system in order to
evaluate the efficiency of its usage as well as possible benefits on
public lighting system and monitoring of low voltage grid
parameters. The results have shown low payback periods and a
promising internal return rate when compared with other
applications, such as saving accounts. The smart grid features on
the controller allows simple integration with renewable sources
and central management and controlling lighting system.
Keywords— Economic Analysis, Power quality parameters,
Smart grid, Smart lighting device, Street lighting system
I. INTRODUCTION
The conventional luminaires applied to street lighting
system are not able to perform communication, control and
management features [1]. Furthermore, the system is also not
capable to measure useful information from the luminaire, i.e.
energy consumption and detection of possible failures in the
luminaire. In this sense, it is possible to notice that the large
majority of street lighting systems were designed using old
equipment and techniques [2]. However, due to the advance in
science as well as the increase number of industrial researches
regarding the development of modern devices and
computational processes, the application of smart and
communication technologies in the conventional street lighting
systems provides prospects for monitoring, management and
automation, allowing the interconnection of different
intelligent devices.
It is noteworthy that the lamp needs to offer flexibility and
high efficiency to accomplish the tasks received from the
controller. Besides, for instance, it is not feasible to perform
dimming control in high-pressure sodium lamps, which are the
most common lamps used in the street lighting systems. In this
context, the LED technology has the advantage to meet all the
necessary requirements [3] and according to [4], its usage has
gained notoriety due to its excellent photometric
characteristics, such as high color rendering index (CRI), high
luminous efficacy (lm / W), high mechanical strength, long
lifespan (up to 100.000 hours) and reduction of light pollution
[5].
It is estimated that about 30% of all electricity generated in
the world is used to produce artificial lighting [6]. Therefore, it
is possible to notice that artificial lighting systems represent a
large potential for energy cost saving. Within this context, the
usage of alternatives to reduce energy consumption in lighting
systems could provide significant economic saving and
reduction of environmental impacts. The so called intelligent
lighting system is integrated with several devices, such as
sensors, lighting fixtures, transceivers, energy meters, among
other elements that allow measurement and controlling of the
whole system through autonomous algorithm [12]. In this way,
it turns possible the usage of available resources to optimize its
functions as well as to solve inheriting issues in lighting
systems.
With the insertion of smart devices in street lighting system
as well as the integration of LED lamps, it is important to
perform a deeply analysis to ensure both technical and
economic feasibility of these types of prototypes. In this sense,
this work aims to perform an economic analysis of a
controllable device with smart grid features applied to LED
street lighting system in order to evaluate the efficiency of its
usage as well as possible benefits on public lighting system.
This paper is organized as follows. In Section II is presented a
detailed description of the developed intelligent device to be
used in smart lighting application as well as to measure power
quality parameters, which was proposed by the authors in [7].
It is proposed in the Section III two critical scenarios to
economics assessment of the smart device in the street lighting
application and they are evaluated using two different dimming
strategies. In Section IV are shown the economic analysis
concerning all the proposed scenarios and it is performed a
978-1-4673-7554-2/15/$31.00 ©2015 IEEE
1184