IEEE ANTENNAS AND WIRELESS PROPAGATION LETTERS, VOL. 9, 2010 1119
Low-Profile Multifrequency HF Antenna Design
for Coastal Radar Applications
James Baker, Hyoung-Sun Youn, Member, IEEE, Nuri Celik, Member, IEEE, and Magdy F. Iskander, Fellow, IEEE
Abstract—A novel design for an electrically small high-fre-
quency (HF) antenna suitable for coastal radar applications is
presented. The principle design objectives were to develop an HF
antenna resonant at multiple frequencies that is also compact
and easily transportable for deployment to coastal sites and
on floating platforms. The compact antenna achieves practical
performance values for radiation resistance, bandwidth, and gain
while maintaining small values of . The design presented in
this letter consists of a meandering line antenna composed of
helical elements and switchable folded arms. The value of
ranges down to 0.16 at 5.7 MHz. The antenna is self-resonant at
multiple frequencies including 5.7, 16.1, 20.6, and 28.1 MHz for
open-circuit mode and 15.1, 18.5, and 26.1 for the short-circuit
mode. In all cases, input impedances were easily matched to 50-
coaxial feed lines, and the achieved bandwidths ranged from 1%
to 12% within the HF band (3–30 MHz). The antenna is 90 cm
high with a small ground disk of 60 cm diameter. Simulation
results and prototype experimental measurements are presented.
Index Terms—Coastal radar, electrically small antenna, ESA,
helical, high-frequency (HF) antenna, meandering line, mean-
dering line antenna (MLA).
I. INTRODUCTION
L
IMITATIONS of current coastal HF radar systems
include the large physical dimensions required for op-
erations at the longer wavelengths of the high-frequency (HF)
band (3–30 MHz). Coastal radar applications require vertical
polarization for long-range surface-wave propagation over the
ocean, so antenna elements tend to be vertical with heights
ranging from 5 to 25 m. Many current systems use quarter-wave
monopole antenna that are omnidirectional, requiring extensive
arrays to accomplish the beamforming required to minimize
clutter and backscatter from the surrounding terrain. Coastal
HF radar system performance is also affected by ionospheric
conditions that are constantly changing and impact the useable
frequencies available. A typical antenna network involves ar-
rays of quarter-wave monopole structures that, in the frequency
range, correspond to antenna lengths of up to 25 m, with even
larger ground radial networks. As a result, current HF surface
wave radar (HFSWR) and over the horizon radar (OTHR)
antenna systems tend to be located at fixed sites with extensive
Manuscript received September 18, 2010; revised November 23, 2010; ac-
cepted November 28, 2010. Date of publication December 03, 2010; date of
current version December 13, 2010. This work was supported in part by the
U.S. Department of Homeland Security under Grant 2008-ST-061-ML0002 to
the School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology, University of Hawaii.
The authors are with the Hawaii Center for Advanced Communications, Col-
lege of Engineering, University of Hawaii, Honolulu, HI 96822 USA (e-mail:
jmbaker@hawaii.edu).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this letter are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/LAWP.2010.2096552
infrastructure and site preparation requirements. These radar
arrays can extend for several kilometers with significant envi-
ronmental impact. In modern coastal radar systems, though, it
is desirable for the system to be readily transportable with short
setup times for rapid deployment to remote and unprepared
sites. For homeland security applications, it is also desirable
that the system be deployable on floating platforms such as
buoys, barges, ships, and other types of seaworthy platforms.
Current coastal radar antennas are not suitable for these types
of floating platforms due to their large size and infrastructure
requirements. In addition to these requirements, it is also de-
sirable to make the antenna structures less recognizable so that
the position of the radar site can be disguised. For these mobile
radar systems, particularly those suitable for surveillance and
homeland security applications, the antenna size is considered
one of the highest design priorities.
Over the years there have been many contributors to the
theory and design of antenna that are electrically small.
Wheeler and Chu pioneered the field by developing funda-
mental limitations in how small an antenna can be designed
while maintaining practical performance [1]–[3]. The generally
accepted criteria for what makes an antenna “electrically small”
is based on the overall volume occupied by the antenna. Using
the free-space wave number and the radius of
the sphere enclosing the antenna, an antenna is considered to
be electrically small if the value of is less than or equal
to 0.5 [4]. For the coastal radar application, the primary char-
acteristics of interest (and limiting factors) in antenna design
are resonance, polarization, impedance, bandwidth, and phase
stability. For the homeland security application, it is also desir-
able that the antenna not be immediately obvious to the casual
observer, yet it is usually not practical to disguise a vertical
antenna that is 5–10 m tall. It remains important though that the
low-profile HF antenna retain acceptable performance. It is also
desirable for the low-profile antenna to be either broadband or
at least have multiple resonances within the HF band to allow
for system operation at different frequencies as atmospheric
and other propagation conditions change.
In this letter, a new HF antenna design is presented, one that is
suitable for coastal radar applications. The new design is low-
profile (less than 1 m high), relatively compact, and provides
for effective performance within the HF band. This new design
combines a helical antenna structure with a meandering line an-
tenna (MLA) and has been shown to provide improved antenna
radiation resistance and strong vertical polarization while main-
taining an omnidirectional radiation pattern with low takeoff
angle. The helical MLA also provides for multiple self-reso-
nance frequencies ranging from 5.7 up to 28 MHz, allowing
for selectable channels, even without the use of external tuning
1536-1225/$26.00 © 2010 IEEE