Research Letter
Practicing healing
James Lake
Deparment of Psychiatry, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, United States
When the familiar routines and comforts of living and working in a
‘developed’ country start to feel empty I sometimes travel to remote
places to get a fresh perspective on life and for spiritual renewal. A few
years ago, depleted by worries about my mother’s precarious health
and discouraged by a series of career disappointments, I found myself
doubting core beliefs that had led to medical school decades earlier.
Could I make a difference to my patients given constraints on health
care in the U.S? Was it even possible to do meaningful work in a culture
where the practice of medicine seems to be more about filling in
blanks on boiler plate electronic documents, managing medication
refills efficiently and optimizing work-flow algorithms than listening
carefully to what patients are saying and responding to what they are
feeling? Given my conflicts, was it ethical for me to continue partici-
pating in the impersonal form imposed on patient care by federal regu-
latory bodies, academic institutions and corporations? And if I could
find a workable compromise that allowed me to ethically practice
medicine, could I find enough meaning to sustain myself while doing
the heart work of compassionately sitting with humans who suffer?
In the midst of my dark night I learned about an opportunity to do
medical volunteer work in a remote area of Tibet. I had gone to con-
ferences on Tibetan medicine and saw this as a way to remind myself
of values that had led to the decision to study medicine, and to find
out whether I still held onto them. While in Tibet I kept a journal to
process experiences and—I already knew then—to help me remember
insights about suffering, what it means to be a physician, and the dif-
ference between treating patients and providing a healing space. The
following narrative was assembled from journal entries made in
Tibet. I hope that others who are also struggling with career disap-
pointments and searching for meaning in the vocation of medicine
will glean something useful from my journey.
I am one of 20 ‘foreign doctors.’ We have come from many coun-
tries to a small town located in the foothills of the Himalayas on the
frontier of Tibet and Mongolia. We’ve come here to serve the nomads
who live in this remote place and to refine our knowledge of “Sowa
rigpa” (Tibetan for ‘the science of healing’). On the morning of the
first day we tour the hospital where we will spend the next month.
We see patients sitting on floors, lying on gurneys in hallways.
A 38-year-old man who is receiving Tibetan style acupuncture
and IV herbal infusion therapy describes symptoms of malaise and
indigestion that started soon after he moved from the high mountain
passes to the city in order to ‘get money’ needed to finance his son’s
college education in a large Chinese city hundreds of miles away.
Before coming here, the man had worked as a yak-herder ‘my heart
did not know how to live in a city.’ Since arriving he has not seen his
son. Looking askance the man says ‘he is learning now. He doesn’t
have time...’ The man doesn’t know where his wife, two young chil-
dren and yaks have gone or when he will see them again.
From a Western medical perspective many patients we have seen
today would be regarded as having ‘ culture-bound syndromes’ reflecting
widely shared Tibetan cultural and spiritual beliefs. Some would probably
be diagnosed with psychosomatic disorders in which stress, anxiety and
depression are experienced as physical symptoms in the absence of an
underlying medical disorder. From the perspective of Tibetan medicine
many have ‘ wind’ disorders or energetic or spiritual disorders that have
led to physical and psychological symptoms. We realize that the high
prevalence of ‘ wind’ disorders probably reflects widespread cultural dis-
location taking place in Tibet and Mongolia as more and more nomads
leave their traditional yak herding roles and move to cities.
After a lunch of yak soup and tsampa (a Tibetan staple made from
ground barley) we begin to see patients. Attired in traditional Tibetan
robes fastened with cloth sashes, dozens of nomads have crowded
into the main hospital entrance and the hallways. Several families
have brought infants and young children. Some arrived last night and
camped in squares of concrete in front of the hospital. We are told
the nomads have been expecting the arrival of ‘foreign doctors’ in
this season, after the yak herds return from the high mountain passes
and before the days grow short. Most mark an ‘X’ at the bottom of a
form when told to do so by the receptionist, then sit on a chair or the
floor and quietly wait. I pick up a form and notice that instructions
are written in Mandarin characters only.
Many patients have already been treated with Chinese medicine,
Tibetan medicine and Western medicine but have not gotten better.
Most are elderly and seek relief from chronic debilitating illnesses
such as heart disease, arthritis, cancer and emphysema. Some have
lost confidence in Tibetan medicine and have been waiting one year
or more for ‘foreign doctors’ to return to cure their maladies. These
patients ask for ‘Western pills’ only. Others reject Western medicine
as unsafe or ineffective. These patients ask for Tibetan medicine only.
Many have physical and psychological symptoms that don’t corre-
spond to a disorder described in Western or Tibetan medicine. Every-
one is desperate to find any treatment that might alleviate suffering.
Daily routine and moments of encounter
My days began at 6:30 with a light breakfast consisting of a few
plums, a handful of nuts, and green tea made with water boiled in a
E-mail address: contact@integrativementalhealth.net
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.explore.2019.07.006
1550-8307/© 2019 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Explore 000 (2019) 1À3
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Explore
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jsch