Power production from a moderate temperature geothermal resource with
regenerative Organic Rankine Cycles
Alessandro Franco
Department of Energy and System Engineering (DESE), University of Pisa, Largo Lucio Lazzarino, 56122 Pisa, Italy
abstract article info
Article history:
Received 7 September 2010
Revised 4 June 2011
Accepted 4 June 2011
Available online 7 July 2011
Keywords:
Moderate-temperature geothermal sources
Organic Rankine Cycle
Binary cycle
Recuperated Rankine cycle
Rejection temperature
Optimum design
Much remains to be done in binary geothermal power plant technology, especially for exploiting low-
enthalpy resources. Due to the great variability of available resources (temperature, pressure, chemical
composition), it is really difficult to “standardize the technology”.The problem involves many different
variables: working fluid selection, heat recovery system definition, heat transfer surfaces sizing and auxiliary
systems consumption. Electricity generation from geothermal resources is convenient if temperature of
geothermal resources is higher than 130 °C. Extension of binary power technology to use low-temperature
geothermal resources has received much attention in the last years. This paper analyzes and discusses the
exploitation of low temperature, water-dominated geothermal fields with a specific attention to regenerative
Organic Rankine Cycles (ORC). The geothermal fluid inlet temperatures considered are in the 100–130 °C
range, while the return temperature of the brine is assumed to be between 70 and 100 °C. The performances
of different configurations, two basic cycle configurations and two recuperated cycles are analyzed and
compared using dry organic fluids as the working fluids. The dry organic fluids for this study are R134a,
isobutane, n-pentane and R245fa. Effects of the operating parameters such as turbine inlet temperature and
pressure on the thermal efficiency, exergy destruction rate and Second Law efficiency are evaluated. The
possible advantages of recuperated configurations in comparison with basic configurations are analyzed,
showing that in a lot of cases the advantage in terms of performance increase is minimal but significant
reductions in cooling systems surface area can be obtained (up to 20%).
© 2011 International Energy Initiative. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Introduction
Moderate-temperature water-dominated systems, with tempera-
tures below 130 °C, account for about 70% of the world's geothermal
energy potential (Barbier, 2002). The distribution of geothermal
energy as function of the resources temperature and the technical
resource potential has been evaluated recently by Stefansson (2005),
starting from a general correlation between the existing geothermal
high temperature resources inferring a total geothermal potential of
200 GWe.
Binary technology allows the use of low temperature water
dominant reservoirs and makes geothermal power production
feasible even for countries lacking high enthalpy resources at shallow
depth. For binary plants two different systems currently are state of
the art, the Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) and the Kalina cycle.
The binary power plants have the least environmental impact due
to the “confinement” of the geofluid. In a binary cycle power plant the
heat of the geothermal water is transferred to a secondary working
fluid, usually an organic fluid that has a low boiling point and high
vapor pressure when compared to water at a given temperature. The
cooled geothermal water is then returned to the ground by the re-
injection well to recharge the reservoir (DiPippo, 2008).
Such a geothermal plant has no emissions to the atmosphere
except for water vapor from the cooling towers (only in case of wet
cooling) and any losses of working fluid. Thus, environmental
problems that may be associated with the exploitation of higher
temperature geothermal resources, like the release of greenhouse
gases (e.g. CO
2
and CH
4
) and the discharge of toxic elements (e.g. Hg
and As) are avoided.
Another advantage of the binary technology is that the geothermal
fluids (or brines) do not contact the moving mechanical components
of the plant (e.g. the turbine), assuring a longer life for the equipment.
Binary plants have allowed the exploitation of a large number of fields
that may have been very difficult (or uneconomic) using other energy
conversion technologies (Schochet, 1997; DiPippo, 2004; Bronicki,
2007).
Of the about 10,700 MW of geothermal plants installed worldwide,
more than 1170 MW use ORC or steam/ORC combined cycles (Bertani,
2010). There exist a great number of studies addressing both the
different characteristics of geothermal fields and the various types of
power plants that could be used in their exploitation for electricity
production; Barbier (2002), Bertani (2005), Lund (2007) and DiPippo
Energy for Sustainable Development 15 (2011) 411–419
E-mail address: alessandro.franco@ing.unipi.it.
0973-0826/$ – see front matter © 2011 International Energy Initiative. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.esd.2011.06.002
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Energy for Sustainable Development