Asian Studies Review. ISSN 1035-7823
Volume 23 Number 2 June 1999
© Asian Studies Association of Australia 1999. Published by Blackwell Publishers, 108 Cowley Road,
Oxford OX4 1JF, UK and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA.
STUDYING “ASIA” IN ASIA
ANTHONY REID
Australian National University
The four following articles have their origin in the concern to internationalise
Asian studies, which emanated from the Association of Asian Studies (AAS) in
the United States and the International Institute of Asian Studies (IIAS) in the
Netherlands in 1996. Asianists in the Asian region, including Australia, were
somewhat marginal participants in this process, although a respectable number
attended the eventual International Congress of Asian Scholars (ICAS) in Noord-
wijkerhout, the Netherlands, in June 1998—the first fruit of this international-
isation initiative. The thoughts which underlie this essay took shape as a keynote
lecture at that conference, the organisers having generously invited one of the
more sceptical participants in the process to speak. It has been rewritten as an
introduction to the set of four articles in this volume, which I initially convened
as a panel on ‘The construction of “Asia” in Asia’ for the 1998 Conference of the
Asian Studies Association of Australia.
INTERNATIONALISATION
The Asian Studies Association of Australia (ASAA), of which I was President
in 1997–98, was predictably the most explicit of the organisations in the Asian
region in doubting the appropriateness of a new phase of internationalisation
which was not centrally concerned with our Asian colleagues. It seemed to us that
the real issue for Asian studies was how or whether it could successfully inter-
nationalise in Asia. The dangerous ambiguities of this question are perhaps par-
ticularly pressing to Asianists from Australia, the country denounced by Samuel
Huntington for contemplating defecting from the West in favour of Asia, and
becoming “a permanently torn country”—his hostile characterisation of cultural
ambivalence (Huntington 1996, 151–53). This opening essay seeks to explore
some of the dilemmas and opportunities for those in the Asian region who would
define their field as “Asian studies”.