Proceedings of the 2012 Winter Simulation Conference
C. Laroque, J. Himmelspach, R. Pasupathy, O. Rose, and A.M. Uhrmacher, eds
A SIMULATION STUDY OF THE EFFECT OF MOSQUE DESIGN ON EGRESS TIMES
Khaled Nassar Ahmed Bayyoumi
The American University in Cairo The American University in Cairo
Dept. of Construction and Architecture Engineering Dept. of Construction and Architecture Engineering
New Cairo, EGYPT New Cairo, EGYPT
ABSTRACT
The Mosque prayer hall is perhaps the only architectural space designed for a large number of floor-
seated occupants. A critical issue in the design of mosques is determining the number and configuration
of exit locations. This paper describes a discrete-event simulation model developed to assess the effect of
mosque prayer hall configuration on the egress times of the occupants. The simulation model takes into
consideration the behavioral aspects of the mosque occupants such as shoe placement and pickup, after
prayer lingering, late egress of front rows, after prayers, and congregations inside and outside the mosque.
Most of the various exit configurations possible in mosque design are modeled and assessed for total
egress time as well as flow rates. It is shown that one-sided exit location out performs all other configura-
tions. The study presents the first such analysis of mosque egress and the results should of great interest to
architects and researchers alike.
1 INTRODUCTION
From an architectural point of view, mosques are unique facilities in that they are the only buildings
where the entire space is occupied by floor-seated individuals. The occupant capacity of the mosque pray-
er halls is probably the highest of all building spaces. Yet international building codes (such as the Inter-
national Building Code IBC) fail to specify appropriate occupant load factors for mosque prayer hall
spaces. More importantly the emergency egress requirements for mosque spaces offer unique challenges
especially when specifying egress number, width, configurations and type. Most if not all building codes
lack specific requirements on emergency egress for mosques. The problem is exacerbated when consider-
ing mosque prayer hall designs in confined areas of larger facilities such as malls and airports, where
limitations exist on the location and design of the means of egress, unlike open mosques. In addition to
the emergency egress and life safety concerns, there is a very limited work done on the level of service
expected in mosque facilities in general and especially at exit corridors or egress access. This often results
in efficient occupant flows in and out of the mosques and places incalculable risks on the lives of the wor-
shippers in case of disasters.
Several unique issues affect emergency egress requirements for mosques during regular and Friday
prayers alike where various occupant loads are expected. For example when considering design standards
and emergency egress requirements for mosques, the intermittent behavior of the occupants after the
prayers (due to social exchanges) should be accounted for as well as other functional reasons such as the
need to put on shoes immediately after exiting the prayer hall, which temporarily blocks the exits. There-
fore, spatial and temporal behavior of the occupants therefore needs to be considered when developing
design standards for mosques. In addition, several questions regarding mosque designs remain open; are
978-1-4673-4780-8/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE 1230 978-1-4673-4782-2/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE