Robust Economic MPC for a Power Management Scenario with
Uncertainties
Tobias Gybel Hovgaard, Lars F. S. Larsen and John Bagterp Jørgensen
Abstract— This paper presents a novel incorporation of
probabilistic constraints and Second Order Cone Program-
ming (SOCP) with economic Model Predictive Control (MPC).
Hereby the performance of the controller is robustyfied in the
presence of both model and forecast uncertainties. Economic
MPC is a receding horizon controller that minimizes an eco-
nomic objective function and we have previously demonstrated
its usage to include a refrigeration system as a controllable
power consumer with a portfolio of power generators such that
total cost is minimized. The main focus for our work is power
management of the refrigeration system. Whereas our previous
study was entirely deterministic, models of e.g. supermarket
refrigeration systems are uncertain, as are forecasts of outdoor
temperatures and electricity demand. The linear program we
have formulated does not cope with uncertainties and thus
it is, liable to drive an optimal solution to an infeasible
or very expensive solution. The main contribution of this
paper is the Finite Impulse Response (FIR) formulation of
the system models, allowing us to describe and handle model
uncertainties in the framework of probabilistic constraints. Our
new solution using this setup for robustifying the economic
MPC is demonstrated by simulation of a small conceptual
example. The scenario is primarily chosen to illustrate the effect
of our proposed method in that it can be compared with our
previous deterministic simulations.
I. I NTRODUCTION
In [1] we introduced economic MPC to control a number
of independent dynamic systems that must collaborate to
minimize the overall cost of satisfying the cooling demand
for some goods while meeting market demands for power
at all times. Our control strategy is an economic optimizing
model predictive controller, economic MPC. MPC for
constrained systems has emerged during the last 30 years
as the most successful methodology for control of industrial
processes [2]. MPC is increasingly being considered for
refrigeration systems [3], [4] and for power production
plants [5]. MPC based on optimizing economic objectives
has only recently emerged as a general methodology with
efficient numerical implementations and provable stability
properties [6]–[8]. Our proposed economic MPC controller
has previously been formulated in a deterministic setting
and the contribution of this paper is to put our strategy
into a more realistic scenario where different uncertainties
always affect the system. Thus, this paper provides a
novel extension to the economic MPC to provide robust
performance in the presence of both forecast and model
T. G. Hovgaard and L. F. S. Larsen are with Danfoss
Refrigeration and A/C Controls, DK-6430 Nordborg, Denmark.
{tgh,lars.larsen}@danfoss.com
J. B. Jørgensen is with DTU Informatics, Technical University of Den-
mark, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark. jbj@imm.dtu.dk
uncertainties. This is done in a way similar to [9] where
energy consumption for climate control is minimized under
influence of uncertain weather predictions but also the
ability to handle model uncertainties in the closed-loop
MPC is an important issue in this paper.
The Smart Grid is the future intelligent electricity grid
and is intended to be the smart electrical infrastructure
required to increase the amount of green energy significantly.
The Danish transmission system operator (TSO) has the
following definition of Smart Grids which we adopt in
this work: ”Intelligent electrical systems that can integrate
the behavior and actions of all connected users - those
who produce, those who consume and those who do
both - in order to provide a sustainable, economical and
reliable electricity supply efficiently” [10]. A larger share
of intermittent stochastic power-generating sources such
as wind turbines makes it difficult to balance demand and
supply of electricity in a flexible and cost-efficient manner.
To account for this we previously introduced large power
consumers, such as cold rooms, or an aggregation of a
number of like consumers such as supermarket systems,
with the ability to adjust the power consumption profile to
the power supply. Due to the large thermal capacity of cold
rooms, their consumption of electricity can, to some degree,
be shifted in time to benefit the overall system. The thermal
capacity in the refrigerated goods is then utilized to store
”coldness” such that the refrigeration system can increase
cooling when there is an over production of energy and
then lower its consumption at other times. The temperature
is allowed to vary within certain bounds, which have no
impact on food quality. We exploit that the dynamics of
the temperature in the cold room are rather slow while the
power consumption can be changed rapidly. [9], [11], [12]
also utilized load shifting capabilities to reduce total energy
consumption.
Several works exist that consider constrained model
predictive control (MPC) in the presence of uncertainty
[13]. In many applications distributions can be quantified for
uncertainty and if this information is ignored (e.g. by defining
worst-case costs and invoking constraints over all uncertainty
realizations) it can lead to conservative results, and the need
for a stochastic extension to constrained MPC is clear [14].
Taking expected values of the cost provides an obvious way
to utilize probabilistic information [15]. However constraints
often admit a probabilistic formulation too, e.g. a variable
should not exceed a certain bound with a given probability.
2011 50th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control and
European Control Conference (CDC-ECC)
Orlando, FL, USA, December 12-15, 2011
978-1-61284-799-3/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE 1515