Ethical Legal Topic
Microaggressions in Clinical Training and Practice
Maryann K. Overland, MD, Jennifer M. Zumsteg, MD, Edwin G. Lindo, JD,
Maurice G. Sholas, MD, PhD, FAAPMR, Roberto E. Montenegro, MD, PhD,
Georgina D. Campelia, PhD,
Feature Editor: Debjani Mukherjee, PhD
Feature Editor: Debjani Mukherjee, PhD
Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine and
Shirley Ryan AbilityLab
The term microaggression was coined almost 50 years
ago (1970) by Professor Chester Pierce and has reemerged
as a topic of scholarly interest, a contested concept, a social
media hashtag, and a polarizing issue in our current political
climate. A classic article from 2007 by Derald Wing Sue and
colleagues defines racial microaggressions as “brief and
commonplace daily verbal, behavioral, or environmental
indignities, whether intentional or unintentional, that com-
municate hostile, derogatory, or negative racial slights and
insults towards people of color.”
1
Sue and colleagues further
define three types of microaggressions. Microassaults are a
“verbal or nonverbal attached meant to hurt the intended
victim through name-calling, avoidant behavior, or purpose-
ful discriminatory actions.” Microinsults are “communica-
tions that convey rudeness and insensitivity and demean a
person’ s racial heritage or identity.” Microinvalidations are
“communications that exclude, negate or nullify the psy-
chological thoughts, feelings, or experiential reality of a
person of color” (p. 274). The term was first applied to race
and racism, however, the term also applies to other margin-
alized groups including women, people with disabilities,
sexual and gender minorities, and religious minorities,
among others.
2
There are critiques of the concept, includ-
ing the observation that the research on microaggressions
is “underdeveloped,” lacks scientific rigor, and may be
“embedded in politics.”
3
Yet, there is agreement that
insults, snubs, and slights undermine relationships and prac-
tices and affect health care.
In a recent PM&R ethics/legal column, guest edited by
Julie Silver, MD, the topic of micro-inequities in medicine
was explored.
4
In this series of invited commentaries, we
will delve into microaggressions. Within medicine, there
is a small but growing body of literature (see for example,
Freeman and Stewart
5
) including microaggressions expe-
rienced by patients, healthcare professionals, and
trainees. Various medical schools have embarked on
microaggression awareness campaigns and incorporated
this concept into education, as have some residency pro-
grams. I have asked the authors to focus specifically on
the experiences of healthcare professionals and trainees.
The topic of microaggressions toward patients is a related
but distinct area of concern. The invited authors were
asked to respond to the following prompt:
How does the experience of microaggressions
impact the practice of medicine? How have your
experiences or those of your colleagues under-
scored the complexities of this concept? Illustrative
examples, particularly from PM&R, are welcome.
What are the ethical implications? Do you have sug-
gestions for decreasing microaggressions, on the
individual, group, institutional or societal level?
Our first columnist, Maryann Katherine Overland, MD, is
an assistant professor of medicine in the Division of Gen-
eral Internal Medicine and the associate program director
of primary care for the Internal Medicine Residency at the
University of Washington. She highlights how trainees can
be supported to mitigate the impact of microaggressions.
Our second contribution is from Jennifer M. Zumsteg, MD,
an associate professor of rehabilitation medicine and pro-
gram director, PM&R Residency and Edwin Lindo, JD, a
lecturer in the Department of Family Medicine and associ-
ate director of critical teaching and equity at the Center
for Critical Teaching and Equity at the Center for Leader-
ship and Innovation in Medical Education, at the Univer-
sity of Washington. They describe historical biases and
draw on examples from PM&R residents. Our third
PM R 11 (2019) 1004–1012
www.pmrjournal.org
© 2019 American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
https://dx.doi.org/10.1002/pmrj.12229