Section Editors
Johan A. Aarli, MD
Oded Abramsky, MD, PhD, FRCP
Global Perspectives
Mamta Bhushan Singh,
MD, DM (Neurology)
Correspondence to
Dr. Singh:
mbsneuro@gmail.com
Supplemental data
at Neurology.org
EPILEPSY IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES:
PERSPECTIVES FROM INDIA
India, with a population of 1.2 billion, has an esti-
mated 12 million persons with epilepsy (PWE). As
70% of Indians are agrarian, more PWE live in vil-
lages and small towns than in big cities. However,
most doctors and hospitals providing epilepsy care
are concentrated in a few large metropolitan cities.
This sets the stage for many of the ills that plague epi-
lepsy care in India.
Untreated epilepsy. Reported estimates of treatment
gap between the north and south of India and also
between rural and urban populations vary (table e-1
on the Neurology
®
Web site at Neurology.org.). For
the most neglected regions, a treatment gap of up to
90% has been reported. While untreated epilepsy
suggests failure of the health care system, it also
constitutes low-lying fruit, where it would be cost-
effective to seek out, diagnose, and initiate
antiepileptic drug (AED) treatment in drug-naive
patients. We know that if patients previously
unexposed to AEDs are treated, at least half of
them are expected to become seizure-free. In other
words, the number needed to treat for such patients is
2. There are few other entities in neurology where
outcome with treatment is expected to be so good.
India is a young nation with more than two-thirds of
the population below age 35 years. Improving
treatment options and availability will empower
PWE to not only improve their own lives but also
participate in and contribute to society.
Consequences of untreated epilepsy. Active epilepsy
with frequent seizures is dangerous, depressing, and
disabling. While medical consequences of seizures
are recognized more easily, the social, economic, psy-
chological, personal, and professional fallout often
escape attention. If a child has epilepsy, there is a high
probability of him or her dropping out of school.
Young PWE are often discriminated against when
seeking employment, forcing them to remain finan-
cially dependent on family, friends, or society. Accep-
tance and fulfilment in a marital relationship is
frequently denied to a PWE, more so if the PWE is
a woman. Stigmatization against PWE in society is
widespread, deep-rooted, and pervasive. Seizures in
untreated patients are often generalized and may
lead to injuries and mutilation (figure). The severe
disability associated with active epilepsy and
frequent ongoing seizures is often forgotten or
overlooked even by experts in the field.
1
What causes the treatment gap? Illiteracy, poor health
awareness in general, and cultural acceptance of alter-
native, mostly unscientific, systems of therapy have
been advanced as reasons for the treatment gap.
While these may have been correct in the past and
may still be true to some extent today, most Indian
villages have urbanized to varying extents and infor-
mation technology has made inroads in many previ-
ously insulated communities. In a survey of 200
rural PWE, all knew that epilepsy was a medical con-
dition and 97% believed they would benefit from
modern medicine.
2
Increasingly, the only reason that
patients cite for not ever having taken treatment in
spite of having had active epilepsy for decades is lack
of access to a doctor. The poignancy of this bottle-
neck is further exaggerated because of the willingness
and ability of thousands of these untreated patients to
buy and consume AEDs if only they could get a pre-
scription. While patients often know that medicines
can help them, lack of information about the details
of treatment, especially that treatment generally has
to be continued for years, leads to a secondary treat-
ment gap where a PWE prematurely stops treatment
and loses seizure control.
Deficit in primary care. Why is it so difficult for pa-
tients in most of rural and semiurban India to consult
a doctor? On paper, there is a hierarchy of functional
government-run facilities responsible for primary
health care needs at various levels, including
villages. On the ground, however, these services are
inconsistent and patchy, and there is in effect no
reliable, uniform primary health care system present
throughout the country. There are regional
disparities, nonuniformity of available resources
between states, and varying degrees of participation
from public and private sectors. The cost of health
From the Department of Neurology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Go to Neurology.org for full disclosures. Funding information and disclosures deemed relevant by the author, if any, are provided at the end of the article.
1592 © 2015 American Academy of Neurology
ª 2015 American Academy of Neurology. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.