Appl. Phys. B 56, 287-293 (1993)
Applied physics
PhysicsB and Laser
Chemistry
© Springer-Verlag 1993
Determination of Temperature by Stimulated Raman Scattering
of Molecular Nitrogen, Oxygen, and Carbon Dioxide
G. Millot, B. Lavorel, G. Fanjoux, C. Wenger
Laboratoire de Spectronomie Mol6cutaire et Instrumentation Laser, Universit6 de Bourgogne, U.R.A. CNRS, 6, Bd. Gabriel, F-21000 Dijon, France
(Tel.: 33-80/39 59 81, Fax: 33-80/39 59 71)
Received 11 November 1992/Accepted 9 February 1993
Abstract. We have determined the temperature from SRS
spectra of N2-N 2, N2-CO 2, 02-02, and CO2-CO 2 recorded
in wide pressure and temperature ranges. The fitting pro-
cedure takes simultaneously into account the Dicke effect
and motional narrowing. We have quantified the accuracy
of the MEG and ECS-P models for rotational relaxation.
The temperature extracted from each model is compared
with thermocouple measurements. The influence of vibra-
tional broadening and shifting is discussed in detail.
PACS: 33.70, 42.65.Dr
Modem optical techniques like coherent anti-Stokes Raman
spectroscopy (CARS) or stimulated Raman spectroscopy
(SRS) have been proven to be effective for temperature
measurement in real combustion environments [1]. Whereas
CARS has demonstrated its usefulness in many applications,
SRS has been especially used for fundamental studies [2].
These fundamental studies are devoted to the determination
of line broadening and line shifting coefficients over a wide
temperature range and to the study of interference effects for
overlapping lines. Self collisions and collisions with minor
species define the Q-branch profile for the probe molecule.
The main collisional systems investigated up to now are
N2-N 2 [3-13], Na-CO 2 [14], N2-H20 [15], N2-CO2-H20
[16], Oa-O 2, O2-N 2 [17, 18], CO2-CO 2 [19,20], and CO-
CO [21,22]. Among these collisional systems, we have been
particularly interested in Nz-N2, N2-CO2, 02-02, and CO 2-
CO 2. The Q-branch Raman spectra have been recorded with
the high-resolution stimulated Raman spectrometer devel-
oped at Dijon a few years ago [3, 4, 6]. The main charac-
teristics of this laser spectrometer are, first, its high spectral
resolution (2.3 x 10 -3 cm-~), and second, its accurate abso-
lute frequency calibration (better than 10 .3 cm -1) [23]. An-
other characteristic is the absence of the nonresonant part of
the Raman signal, since the stimulated Raman process only
depends on the imaginary part of the susceptibility. We
have taken advantage of these properties for developing
and testing different models describing rotational relaxation
rates, by comparison between calculated spectra and SRS
experimental data over a wide density range. Among these
models, we have focused our attention on the MEG law
[7] used in practical applications and on the ECS-P law
[9] which has a more physical background. The nonlinear
susceptibility gives a spectral shape which depends on
pressure and temperature. The synthetic shape depends on
modeling of the rotational relaxation rates and consequently
measurements of medium properties will also depend on the
model used for these relaxation rates.
In our previous studies [9, 11, 14, 17-20], we have com-
pared the MEG and ECS-P models and we have given promi-
nence to their different behavior for modeling of line broad-
ening coefficient and collisional line narrowing in the Q-
branch. The main goal of this report is to explicitly test
the accuracy of these models for the temperature determi-
nation. So, we have developed a computer routine which
allows us to fit the temperature in wide pressure and tem-
perature ranges, which works for a mixture of several gases
and which takes simultaneously into account the Dicke effect
and motional narrowing. The temperature is fit to SRS Q-
branches recorded in a temperature-controlled cell equipped
with a thermocouple. A large part of the data comes from
previous studies, except for pure nitrogen, for which a spec-
trum at 730 K has been especially recorded for this work,
and also except for spectra of N2-N 2 at 140 K and CO 2-
CO 2 at temperatures above 500 K (unpublished results). We
have not tried to modify the models to obtain the exact tem-
perature, our aim being to quantify the precision of each
simple model for temperature fit from a more physical point
of view. Many studies have been reported up to now in
CARS thermometry ([24-28], and references therein), show-
ing that several precautions should be taken in order to avoid
systematic errors in the determination of the temperature.
Among the parameters which may induce systematic errors
let us note the nonresonant third-order susceptibility - (3~
/'((NR)'
the absolute frequency calibration, the spectral dispersion of
the detection system, cross coherence effects between ele-
mentary CARS polarizations when a multimode pump laser
source is used, nonlinearities in the response of intensified
diode array detectors, effects of finite pump-laser bandwidth,