Labour markets in developing countries
While most research in labour economics focuses on the US and
Western Europe, the majority of the world's population and particularly
of the poor and the youth live in countries where labour markets often
function quite differently. This special issue is intended to stimulate and
promote research on employment and labour economics in developing
countries.
In many developing countries, labour markets are characterized by
a large informal sector, many small-scale production units, household
firms and farms, labour supply decisions of large households, limited
coverage of social protection and insurance, often large uninsured
risks such as natural catastrophes, etc. The stock of knowledge on how
labour markets function and how policies, labour markets, incomes and
poverty interact is certainly much lower than for developed countries.
At the same time, given the still high levels of poverty, hunger, sickness,
violence and bleak outlooks due to climate change and population
growth, knowledge would be even more valuable.
In developing and particularly in the low income countries, labour
markets have for long been characterised by weak demand for labour
due to stagnant growth performance and unprecedented supply of
labour fuelled by population growth. Partly due to globalisation and
the rapid economic transformation of the BIC (Brazil/India/China)
countries, in recent decades growth has improved considerably
in most of the developing world, also boosting labour demand.
Nevertheless, labour demand is often still far from matching the
level of labour supply in countries with growing populations.
The labour markets in developing countries also have several aspects
that make them different from what labour economics has dealt with
traditionally. These include: the existence of large urban informal
sectors; a huge agricultural sector with small-scale farming activities
as the mainstay in many cases; high levels of rural–urban migration;
high levels of unemployment and underemployment; weak private
sectors and a low productivity enterprise culture often involving
micro- and household-enterprises with unpaid family workers;
small capital stock; social pressure and social obligations that limit
incentives for firms to grow; lack of empowerment of women and
the youth in particular; rampant child labour; poor quality of
human capital also due to poor education and poor health systems
or low nutrition. Such differences are also visible in labour relations,
with a higher fraction of casual versus permanent labour contracts, as
well as “coercive” labour relations (Acemoglu, 2011, Econometrica).
A related issue has to do with (formal) labour market institutions
and regulations often being weak or non-existent, particularly in the
poorest countries. There is often limited coverage of social protection
and insurance. In addition, the social protection systems are often
tailored to the formal sector, thus poorly protecting the large share
of people working in the informal sector. Furthermore, attempts to
reach out to the informal sector have many times generated further
distortions. The existing stock of knowledge on how labour markets
operate and, generally, how labour market policies and institutions
influence incomes, levels of poverty and social welfare and mobility
is more limited for developing countries than for rich European and
North-American countries. At the same time, it is in the developing
world that high levels of absolute poverty and its usual manifestations
such as hunger, ill health and violence exist and have to be addressed.
It is also in the developing world where one finds the ‘lands of conflict
or broken states’, to use the words of the World Development Report
2011 (World Bank, 2011), where millions get displaced from their
livelihoods and jobs due to conflict. These aspects, together with
labour often being the only asset for most people in the developing
world, underscore the daunting task awaiting research in labour
economics to influence changes in lives and livelihoods.
The recent financial crisis may also remind us that a quick solution to
all these problems is unlikely to be expected soon. After an unprecedented
economic boom in the developing world thanks to globalisation and, in
particular, the influence of the BIC (Brazil/India/China) countries, the
great recession that started in 2008 in the US is still lingering across
most of the developed world. This recession is also threatening to wipe
out some of the progress made in the developing world in terms of jobs
and employment in recent decades. ILO's latest Global Employment
Trends (ILO 2011) report a stagnation in progress in reducing vulnerable
employment and slowed progress in reducing working poverty in the
developing world. Lack of social security and effective institutions to
deal with the consequences of the economic crisis adds to the affliction
of the lives of millions in the developing world.
Empirical research on labour markets in developing countries is
often complicated by less reliable and imperfect data, making the precise
estimation of policy impacts and causal effects difficult. For most low
income countries one can only dream of good quality longitudinal
data, linked employer–employee data and administrative register
data with large sample sizes and low measurement error. Primary
data collection on firms in the informal sector or of longitudinal data on
households and individuals is not an easy and costless task. In addition,
there does not yet seem to be a consensus on the most appropriate
theoretical model for labour markets in developing countries. For
example the debate on whether informality is voluntary or involuntary
is still on-going, and while it is easy to agree that some people are
voluntarily and others are involuntarily informal, this does not help
for policy making. Models need to incorporate both facets, and then
not only test whether they are true but also quantify the effects of
possible reforms. For informed policy making one would therefore
require an even larger stock of research results than for developed
countries, even more so once one acknowledges the large heterogeneity
across developing countries. Equally important is the need to strengthen
the interface between research and policy making in the developing
Labour markets in developing countriesLabour Economics 18 (2011) S2–S6 Labour Economics 18 (2011) S2–S6
0927-5371/$ – see front matter © 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.labeco.2011.10.003
Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect
Labour Economics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/labeco