Optimization Based - Approach for Organizing the Bidding of Nonserial
Repetitive Projects
A. Samer Ezeldin
1
and Ahmed M. Alhady
2
1
Professor and Graduate Director, Department of Construction and Architectural
Engineering, The American University in Cairo, Egypt; AUC Avenue, P.O. Box 74,
New Cairo 11835, Egypt; PH (202) 2615-2631; email: aezeldin@aucegypt.edu.
2
PhD Candidate, Department of Construction and Architectural Engineering, The
American University in Cairo, Egypt; AUC Avenue, P.O. Box 74, New Cairo
11835, Egypt; PH (201) 00-180-4706; email: hady79@aucegypt.edu.
ABSTRACT
In practice, the number of contracts and the categories of contractors to be
called for bidding on non-serial repetitive projects under one major program are often
estimated based on intuition and experience. It may involve emotional reactions to
existing surrounding conditions. Accordingly, the factors that form the possible
different scenarios should be properly analyzed and evaluated. This paper introduces
an analytical model that allows for decisions on the number of contracts and projects
per contractors for different contractors’ categories within major construction
infrastructure programs. These optimum decisions are reached using an integrated
time and cost objective. Genetic Algorithm has been employed for performing
optimization. A computer- based model has been developed and validated.
Keywords:
Nonserial Repetitive Projects; Bidding Analysis; Optimization; Time Cost Trade-Off.
INTRODUCTION
Nonserial repetitive construction projects, in this paper, are representing
multi-subprojects under a major program with one defined budget. Therefore, the
word repetitive projects here refers to projects level not activities level. Those sub-
projects are typical in their work packages, activities, and construction methods.
However, they can have different quantities, locations, list prices, and different
contractors. Each subproject is independently related to the others in terms of starting
and finishing dates. In other words, it is not a condition for one subproject to start
after another one is finished. Examples of this kind of projects can be mostly noticed
in infrastructure projects such as roads, railways, tunnels, bridges, pipelines, etc. In
this study, the word cost refers to the cost of owner and the word price refers to the
bid price of a contractor.
In projects that have a nonserial repetitive nature under a grand project, there can
be many different scenarios when deciding upon the number of contracts and
contractors’ categories to be called for bidding. These estimations have to be properly
determined in order to minimize the cost and time of the grand project especially for
infrastructure projects that takes a big share of governments’ capital.
The dilemma is that if the contracts are divided into a small numbers with high
contract value, limited contractors from high categories have to be called for bidding
in order to undertake the project. In this case, this category of contractors has a high
1468 Construction Research Congress 2014 ©ASCE 2014