VOL. 88-B, No. 3, MARCH 2006 315
Five-year prospective clinical and
radiological results of a new cannulated
cemented polished Tri-Taper femoral stem
R. E. Field,
P. J. Singh,
A. M. H. Latif,
M. D. Cronin,
D. J. Matthews
From Epsom and St
Helier University
Hospital NHS Trust,
Carshalton, England
" R. E. Field, PhD,
FRCS(Orth), Consultant
Orthopaedic Surgeon and
Director of Orthopaedic
Research
South West London Elective
Orthopaedic Centre
Epsom General Hospital,
Dorking Road, Epsom,
Surrey KT18 7EG, UK.
" P. J. Singh, MRCS,
Specialist Orthopaedic
Registrar
Oxford Rotation, Nuffield
Orthopaedic Centre,
Windmill Road, Headington,
Oxford OX3 7LD, UK.
" A. M. H. Latif, MBBChir,
Research Fellow
" M. D. Cronin, MRCS,
Research Fellow
" D. J. Matthews, MRCS,
Research Fellow
Orthopaedic Research Unit
St Helier Hospital, Epsom
and St Helier University
Hospitals NHS Trust, Wrythe
Lane, Carshalton, Surrey
SM5 1AA, UK.
Correspondence should be
sent to Mr R. E. Field; e-mail:
richardefield@aol.com
©2006 British Editorial
Society of Bone and
Joint Surgery
doi:10.1302/0301-620X.88B3.
17314 $2.00
J Bone Joint Surg [Br]
2006;88-B:315-20.
Received 17 October 2005;
Accepted 9 November 2005
We describe the results at five years of a prospective study of a new tri-tapered polished,
cannulated, cemented femoral stem implanted in 51 patients (54 hips) with osteoarthritis.
The mean age and body mass index of the patients was 74 years and 27.9, respectively.
Using the anterolateral approach, half of the stems were implanted by a consultant
orthopaedic surgeon and half by six different registrars. There were three withdrawals from
the study because of psychiatric illness, a deep infection and a recurrent dislocation. Five
deaths occurred prior to five-year follow-up and one patient withdrew from clinical review.
In the remaining 51 hips the mean pre-operative Oxford hip score was 47 points which
decreased to 19 points at five years (45 hips). Of the stems 49 (98%) were implanted within
1˚ of neutral in the femoral canal. The mean migration of the stem at five years was 1.9 mm
and the survivorship for aseptic loosening was 100%. There was no significant difference in
outcome between the consultant and registrar groups. At five years, the results were
comparable with those of other polished, tapered, cemented stems. Long-term surveillance
continues.
We describe the results at a maximum of five
years of a pilot study of a new cannulated, tri-
tapered, polished, femoral stem for use in
cemented or hybrid hip replacement.
The study had three aims: 1) to identify
whether a combination of the design features
reported in the literature as advantageous
could produce a successful new implant; 2) to
determine if the new design would deliver a
consistently good clinical outcome when im-
planted by surgeons of differing experience;
and 3) to evaluate the clinical performance of
the new design before its commercial release.
The successful long-term fixation of the
Charnley (Depuy Orthopaedics Inc., Warsaw,
Indiana), Exeter (Stryker, Herouville, France)
and Müller (Zimmer Inc., Warsaw, Indiana)
stems has demonstrated the suitability of stain-
less steel for the manufacture of cemented fem-
oral stems.
1-5
Mediolateral and anteroposterior longitudi-
nal tapers provide a wedge-shaped stem which
transfers compressive load to the cement-bone
interface. A third lateral to medial taper is
reported to enhance load transfer from the
stem to the medial cortex of the proximal
femur.
6
A polished stem allows subsidence
within the cement mantle.
7
Longitudinal can-
nulation of a stem enables implantation to be
done over a guide wire which has been screwed
into the centre of the distal femoral cement
restrictor. This ensures that the tip of the
implanted stem is situated close to the centre of
the femoral canal.
8
The guide wire can be
removed once the cement has polymerised.
Longitudinal recesses with smooth edges on
the anterior, posterior and lateral aspects of the
proximal portion enhance rotational stability
within the cement mantle and help to resist the
torsional stresses which are known to cause
posterior rotation of the stem.
7,9
Reproduction
of the normal femoral geometry gives a com-
ponent with a neck-shaft angle and stem-head
offset within the physiological range.
10,11
Patients and Methods
The Tri-Taper stems were produced from
wrought, high-nitrogen stainless steel in four
sizes ranging in length from 130 mm to 140
mm with the offset increasing incrementally
from 37.2 mm to 47.3 mm. Pre-clinical fatigue
testing was performed in accordance with the
ISO7206-4
12
and ISO7206-8
13
standards. All
the components had a neck-shaft angle of 135˚
and a polished finish with a surface roughness
of 0.2 mRa. The trunnion was a 12/14 Euro-
cone Morse taper suitable for attachment of
cobalt chrome, stainless steel or ceramic mod-
ular heads. The proximal end of the stem can-
nulation was recessed and threaded for attach-