International Journal of Biodiversity and Conservation Vol. 3(12), pp. 637-649, November 2011
Available online at http://www.academicjournals.org/IJBC
ISSN 2141-243X ©2011 Academic Journals
Full Length Research Paper
Oak gall wasps (Hymenoptera: Cynipidae) species
composition using diversity and similarity indexes
across different locations of Oak forest, West-
Azerbaijan, Iran
Mohammed-Reza Zargaran*, Sargon Odisho, Farokh-Takin Babakhani and Bagher
Hoseinpour
Agicultural and Natural Resources Research Center of West-Azerbaijan, Uremia, Iran.
Accepted 27 September, 2011
Patterns of the distribution of species diversity are the result of ecological, physical and historical
factors. Beta diversity is an important property of ecosystems because it provides information about
the partitioning of habitats by species. The objectives of this study were to determine the level of oak
gall wasps diversity present in five different locations and to study the similarity among these
locations. The highest amount of Simpson (0.95) and Shannon (2.6) entropy index were recorded in
Ghabre-hossein and Dare-ghabr. The Jaccard and Sorensen coefficients revealed extremely close
results with multiple site similarity. The multiple-similarity measures indicated that similarity in gall
composition and community between collecting sites was generally between 0.25 and 0.97. Our results
suggest that more oak gall wasps species had an aggregated distribution, and gall wasps diversity
shows a strong beta diversity component. Presence of the rare gall wasps species affected on multiple
site similarity value. Difference in the local distribution of oak species, especially oak subspecies, and
the climate of the locations shall be considered as one main factor in species diversity and the
distribution of gall wasp species in different locations.
Key words: Diversity, gall, wasps, similarity, community, distribution.
INTRODUCTION
The number of equally-common species required to give
a particular value of an index is called the "effective
number of species". This is the true diversity of the
community. Converting indices to true diversities
(effective numbers of species) gives a set of common
behaviors and properties. After conversion, diversity is
always measured in units of the number of species (Jost,
2006). Beta diversity is generally thought of as the
change in diversity among various Alpha diversities
(variation in species composition among geographic
regions) (Magurran, 2004). There exists a wide variety of
methods for measuring Beta diversity, among which
similarity measures are the simplest and the most
commonly used for calculating Beta diversity from
*Corresponding author. E-mail: Zargaran391@yahoo.com. Tel:
00989149371708. Fax: 00984412622221.
abundance or presence/absence data (Wolda, 1981;
Koleff et al., 2003). Both diversity and similarity indices
can be used to compare differences between
communities or samples from communities (Peet, 1974;
Koleff et al., 2003, Magurran, 2004). The classical
Jaccard (1912) and Sorensen (1948) indices were based
on both the number of species present in samples and
the numbers only seen in each of them (Koleff et al.,
2003). Sorenson’s measure is regarded as one of the
most effective presence/absence similarity measures
(Sørensen, 1948; Wolda, 1981). Lennon et al. (2001)
noted that if samples differ greatly in terms of their
species richness, Sorenson measures will always be
large. Another simple mathematical equation that
measures the similarity of pairs of sites is the Jaccard
index (Magurran, 1988). The widely used Sorensen and
Jaccard similarity index led to identification of species
composition in each of the two sites and the species shared
between them (Novotny and Weiblen, 2005). Morisita index