[Global Meteorology 2012; 1:e1] [page 1]
Coupling soil-vegetation-
atmosphere-transfer model
with energy balance model for
estimating energy and water
vapor fluxes over an olive
grove in a semi-arid region
Jamal Ezzahar,
1,2
Salah Er-Raki,
3
Hamid Marah,
1
Said Khabba,
2
Noureddine
Amenzou,
1
Ghani Chehbouni
4
1
Water and Climate Unity, CNESTEN,
Rabat, Morocco;
2
Department of Physics,
Faculty of Sciences Semlalia, Marrakech,
Morocco;
3
LP2M2E, Équipe
d’Instrumentation, Métrologie et
Procédés (IMP), Department of Physics,
Faculty of Sciences and Technology,
Marrakech, Morocco;
4
CESBIO – UMR
CNRS-CNES-IRD-UPS, Toulouse, France
Abstract
Simple soil-vegetation-transfer (SVAT) and
energy balance models were used to estimate
the surface turbulent fluxes (i.e. sensible and
latent heat fluxes) over a complex olive grove
using thermal infra-red surface temperature
(TIRST). This approach used a dual source
SVAT model to calculate the sensible heat flux-
es from radiometric surface temperature.
These fluxes were then used together with the
estimates of the available energy also derived
from TIRST to estimate the latent heat flux by
applying the first law of thermodynamics i.e.
the conservation of energy principle. The data
used to validate this approach were collected
over an irrigated olive grove site located in
central Morocco near Marrakech. Mass and
energy fluxes, as well as micrometeorological
parameters, were continuously measured dur-
ing the year 2003. The comparison between
estimated and measured daily sensible heat
fluxes yielded an acceptable agreement in
spite of the complexity of the study surface
with a correlation coefficient (R²=0.86) and
root mean square error (RMSE) of 28 Wm
–2
.
For the latent heat fluxes, the statistical result
for the comparison between estimated and
measured daily values showed a larger scatter
than that revealed for the sensible heat fluxes
(R²=0.75; RMSE=31.42 Wm
–2
). However, the
correspondence is to be considered acceptable
given the difficulty in estimating latent heat
flux over such a complex field. Therefore, it
can be concluded that, in spite of the simplici-
ty of the proposed approach, it can be consid-
ered a suitable tool for estimating the turbu-
lent fluxes using TIRST over complex surfaces.
Introduction
An accurate determination of regional tur-
bulent fluxes of sensible heat (H) and latent
heat (LE) at the land-atmosphere interface are
required in a wide variety of applications.
Agricultural and forestry research uses these
convective fluxes to predict crop growth.
Meteorologists need accurate estimates of
latent and sensible heat surface fluxes for
weather predictions. Biologists aim to have a
better understanding of how ecosystems func-
tion. Climatologists need estimates of how the
land surface and its vegetation may influence
climate, and hydrologists use estimates for
water balance simulations on different scales.
With the high cost of measuring turbulent
fluxes, a strong emphasis has been directed
toward understanding the processes governing
the exchange of water and energy between the
land surface and the atmosphere in order to
model turbulent fluxes at the different ranges
of the space-time scale. The model parameter-
ization of the interaction between a land sur-
face and the atmosphere is known as a soil-
vegetation-atmosphere transfer scheme
(SVAT). Numerous SVAT schemes of varying
complexity have been developed in recent
years. These SVAT schemes have been used in
conjunction with thermal infra-red data (i.e.
radiometric surface temperature) to estimate
accurate turbulent fluxes.
1-7
Most of these
investigations consist of estimating sensible
heat flux, net radiation and soil heat flux from
thermal infra-red data and calculating latent
heat flux as a residual term of the energy bal-
ance equation by applying the simplified
expression of the first law of thermodynamics.
The latter is referred to as the conservation of
energy principle, meaning that energy can nei-
ther be created nor destroyed, but rather trans-
formed into various forms.
Estimating reliable values of sensible heat
flux represents the most problematic aspect of
this approach. In such model parameteriza-
tions, the soil-vegetation system is treated as a
single source of heat exchange with the over-
lying atmosphere. These kinds of SVAT are
classified as one-layer models. The heat flux is
related to the difference between the radio-
metric temperature and the air temperature at
a reference height. This approximation is still
acceptable over homogenous surfaces where
the vegetation is very dense and short or over
bare soil. However, in most cases, the land-
scape is under partial vegetation canopy so
that both soil and vegetation components con-
tribute to the sensitive heat exchange.
8
Therefore, extension of the one-layer models to
sparsely vegetated surfaces can produce sig-
nificant errors in predicted heat fluxes.
9
In this
context, much effort has been made to investi-
gate the parameterization of heat transfer and
to improve the accuracy in estimating heat
fluxes over different land surface cover by
developing models which explicitly treat the
energy exchanges between the soil, vegetation
and the overlying atmosphere.
9
Lhomme et al.
have considered that the soil-vegetation sys-
tem can be approximated with a two-layer
model where the energy fluxes are partitioned
between the soil and vegetation. They found
that the estimated heat fluxes from thermal
infra-red data over the millet crop using a two-
layer model showed good results compared to
the use of a one-layer model which over-esti-
mates the sensible heat flux.
In this specific study, we will investigate the
applicability of the two-layer model developed by
Lhomme et al.
9
over a more complicated sur-
face. The complexities are related to the sparse-
ness of the vegetation, the heterogeneity of the
soil characteristics and, most importantly, the
heterogeneity in terms of soil moisture induced
by the irrigation method of flood irrigation,
which has an irregular pattern in space and
time. Additionally, the validation of the model
will be performed over an extended period
(measurements taken over approximately one
year) in order to test its consistency for accu-
rately estimating heat fluxes under all weather
conditions. Data used in these investigations
were collected within the framework of the
SUDMED project,
10
which was carried out in
southern Mediterranean regions (Marrakech,
Morocco) to assess the spatio-temporal variabil-
Global Meteorology 2012; volume 1:e1
Correspondence: Jamal Ezzahar, Water and
Climate Unity, CNESTEN, Rabat, Morocco.
E-mail: ezzahar@cnesten.org.ma
Acknowledgments: this research was conducted
within the framework of the SUDMED project,
the EU funded IRRIMED (www.irrimed.org), and
RAF 5058 projects. We are grateful to the
International Joint Laboratory (TREMA) for its
financial and technical support.
Contributions: all authors agree to the contents
and submission of the paper.
Key words: sensible heat flux, latent heat flux,
soil-vegetation-transfer model, thermal infra-red
data, available energy, olive grove, semi-arid
region.
Received for publication: 15 June 2011.
Revision received: 23 March 2012.
Accepted for publication: 28 March 2012.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution 3.0 License (by-nc 3.0).
©Copyright J. Ezzahar et al., 2012
Licensee PAGEPress, Italy
Global Meteorology 2012; 1:e1
doi:10.4081/gm.2012.e1
Non-commercial use only