Corneal Viscoelastic Properties from Finite-Element
Analysis of In Vivo Air-Puff Deformation
Sabine Kling, Nandor Bekesi, Carlos Dorronsoro, Daniel Pascual, Susana Marcos*
Instituto de O
´
ptica ‘‘Daza de Valde ´s’’, Madrid, Spain
Abstract
Biomechanical properties are an excellent health marker of biological tissues, however they are challenging to be measured
in-vivo. Non-invasive approaches to assess tissue biomechanics have been suggested, but there is a clear need for more
accurate techniques for diagnosis, surgical guidance and treatment evaluation. Recently air-puff systems have been
developed to study the dynamic tissue response, nevertheless the experimental geometrical observations lack from an
analysis that addresses specifically the inherent dynamic properties. In this study a viscoelastic finite element model was
built that predicts the experimental corneal deformation response to an air-puff for different conditions. A sensitivity
analysis reveals significant contributions to corneal deformation of intraocular pressure and corneal thickness, besides
corneal biomechanical properties. The results show the capability of dynamic imaging to reveal inherent biomechanical
properties in vivo. Estimates of corneal biomechanical parameters will contribute to the basic understanding of corneal
structure, shape and integrity and increase the predictability of corneal surgery.
Citation: Kling S, Bekesi N, Dorronsoro C, Pascual D, Marcos S (2014) Corneal Viscoelastic Properties from Finite-Element Analysis of In Vivo Air-Puff
Deformation. PLoS ONE 9(8): e104904. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0104904
Editor: Craig Boote, Cardiff University, United Kingdom
Received May 1, 2014; Accepted July 15, 2014; Published August 14, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Kling et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: The authors confirm that all data underlying the findings are fully available without restriction. All relevant data are within the paper and its
Supporting Information files.
Funding: Spanish Government FIS2011-25637, European Research Council ERC-2011 AdG-294099 to SM. FPI-BES-2009-024560 Pre-doctoral Fellowship to SK. The
funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
* Email: susana@io.cfmac.csic.es
Introduction
The demand for measuring biomechanical properties of
biological tissue in-vivo and non-invasively is high, because
abnormal tissue biomechanics play a key role in a wide range of
diseases. The stress distribution [1] around and stiffness [2] of
tumor tissue largely determine its progression. Biomechanical
properties are also indicative of muscle function [3] and the effects
of disease, wound healing [4], aging or cosmetics [5].
In ophthalmology, ocular biomechanics are essential for basic
research, clinical evaluation, prognosis and treatment. Patholog-
ical weakening of the cornea appears to be responsible for the
corneal bulging, and dramatic visual degradation in keratoconus.
Corneal collagen cross-linking is an emerging treatment to
increase corneal stiffness in this disease [6]. Theoretical models
that integrate individual mechanical, geometrical and structural
patient data have the potential to improve clinical outcomes of eye
surgery, but depend largely on the identification of pre-operative
biomechanical parameters. Most frequently only the elastic tissue
properties are evaluated, more specifically the elasticity modulus.
However, also time-dependent mechanical properties are expected
to matter, along with active remodeling processes. For example,
the progressive deformation of the cornea (ectasia) occurring in
keratoconus [17] and after some laser refractive procedures [18],
may result from an altered stress distribution of the cornea
inducing viscoelastic deformation until the new steady state is
reached. Also certain treatments such as UV corneal collagen
cross-linking (CXL) likely modify both elastic and viscoelastic
properties. Changes in the degree of collagen interweaving,
keratocyte density or the presence of hydrophilic proteoglycans
may result in the viscoelastic failure or abnormal repair [19].
Today, most information regarding available corneal biome-
chanical properties was assessed ex vivo [7,8,9,10], where changes
in the hydration state [9] and other non-physiological conditions
affect the measurement.
In vivo approaches to measure corneal biomechanical proper-
ties include stepwise indentation with a cantilever [11]; ultrasonic
[12] and magnetic resonance [13] techniques; corneal optical
coherence elastography [14]; phase-sensitive [15] Optical Coher-
ence Tomography (OCT); and Brillouin microscopy [16].
Drawbacks of several of these techniques include that they only
can be operated at low speed, have a low spatial resolution or
require contact with the patient’s corneal surface.
Studying the dynamic deformation following an air-puff has
recently been proposed in different biomedical areas (skin [5],
bacteria [20], cornea [21], soft tissue tumors [22]) to non-
invasively assess biomechanical properties, but also in other fields
to study chicken embryogenesis [23], fruit firmness [24] or meat
tenderness [25]. In most cases the degree of deformation of the
sample is empirically related to mechanical parameters, and the
inherent mechanical parameters of the tissue were rarely retrieved.
To our knowledge, only Boyer et al [5] proposed an analytical
estimation of the ‘‘restricted Young’s modulus’’ from experimental
deformation curves in skin.
Air puff applanation of the cornea is a frequent technique in
ophthalmology to measure intraocular pressure, yet requiring
correction formulae to account for corneal thickness and stiffness.
PLOS ONE | www.plosone.org 1 August 2014 | Volume 9 | Issue 8 | e104904