Phase, Compositional, and Morphological Changes
of Human Dentin after Nd:YAG Laser Treatment
Chun-Pin Lin, DDS, MS, PhD, Bor-Shiunn Lee, DDS, MS, Feng-Huei Lin, PhD, Sang-Heng Kok, DDS, and
Wan-Hong Lan, DDS, DDsc
Although techniques for repairing root fracture
have been proposed, the prognosis is generally
poor. If the fusion of a root fracture by laser is
possible, it will offer an alternative to extraction.
Our group has attempted to use lasers to fuse a
low melting-point bioactive glass to fractured den-
tin. This report is focused on the phase, composi-
tional, and morphological changes observed by
means of X-ray diffractometer, Fourier transform-
ing infrared spectroscopy, and scanning electron
microscopy-energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy
in human dentin after exposure to Nd:YAG laser.
The irradiation energies were from 150 mJ/
pulse-10 pps-4 s to 150 mJ/pulse-30 pps-4 s. After
exposure to Nd:YAG laser, dentin showed four
peaks on the X-ray diffractometer that corre-
sponding to -tricalcium phosphate (TCP) and
-TCP at 2 30.78 degrees/34.21 degrees and
32.47 degrees/33.05 degrees, respectively. The
peaks of -TCP and -TCP gradually increased in
intensity with the elevation of irradiation energy. In
Fourier transforming infrared analysis, two absorp-
tion bands at 2200 cm
1
and 2015 cm
1
could be
traced on dentin treated by Nd:YAG laser with the
irradiation energies beyond 150 mJ/pulse-10 pps-4
s. The energy dispersive X-ray results showed that
the calcium/phosphorus ratios of the irradiated
area proportionally increased with the elevation of
irradiation energy. The laser energies of 150 mJ/
pulse-30 pps-4 s and 150 mJ/pulse-20 pps-4 s
could result in the -TCP formation and collagen
breakdown. However, the formation of glass-like
melted substances without -TCP at the irradiated
site was induced by the energy output of 150 mJ/
pulse-10 pps-4 s. Scanning electron micrographs
also revealed that the laser energy of 150 mJ/
pulse-10 pps-4 s was sufficient to prompt melting
and recrystallization of dentin crystals without
cracking. Therefore, we suggest that the irradia-
tion energy of Nd:YAG laser used to fuse a low
melting-point bioactive glass to dentin is 150 mJ/
pulse-10 pps-4 s.
It has been 30 yr since lasers were first used in dentistry. Despite
substantial development in this field in the United States, only
Er:YAG laser has been granted marketing permission for use on
dental hard tissues. The responses of soft tissues to lasers of
different wavelengths are fairly well known, but the reactions of
hard tissues are just being understood. Nd:YAG laser has long
been investigated for its application in dental treatment. Previous
studies suggested that Nd:YAG laser may function as an alterna-
tive or adjunctive therapy in the treatment of periodontally dis-
eased root surfaces (1), endodontically infected teeth (2), incipient
dental caries (3), and dentin hypersensitivity (4 – 6). Arakawa et al.
(7) induced root fractures, irradiated them by Nd:YAG laser with
air/water surface cooling, and then filled the fractures with a paste
of tricalcium phosphate (TCP). Levy and Koubi (8) tested the
permeability of a cracked root after crack lines had been filled with
a TCP melted by a Nd:YAG laser. However, the decomposition
temperature for pure apatite has been reported to be up to 1500°C
(9), at which damage including multiple cracks of dentin may
occur.
The effect of lasers on dentin is caused mainly by the changes
in temperature that can be extremely high at the irradiated spot
even for a short action time. Consequently, the dentin melts,
vaporizes, and a crater is formed at the irradiation site. Laser
energy causes a quick local temperature rise and prompts melting,
recrystallization, and decomposition of the apatite crystals. Heat
conduction should lead to a thermal equalization between the
pronouncedly heated components and the surrounding tissues
when a laser pulse of the order of a few microseconds is used.
The phase transformation and structural changes of the enamel
at different temperature intervals have been investigated (10).
However, similar changes in the dentin are less well known.
According to the study of Kantola (11), recrystallization of the
dentin occurred during CO
2
laser irradiation. Simultaneously,
growth in the crystal size was observed, and dentin of a low order
of crystallinity changed structurally in such a way that it came to
closely resemble the crystalline structure of the hydroxyapatite of
normal enamel. Similar results were obtained with Nd:YAG laser
that produced significant recrystallization and grain growth of the
JOURNAL OF ENDODONTICS Printed in U.S.A.
Copyright © 2001 by The American Association of Endodontists VOL. 27, NO. 6, JUNE 2001
389