Rawls in Portugal and Spain
João Cardoso Rosas University of Minho, Portugal
abstract: First, this article puts forth a political and cultural explanation for the
fact that the work of Rawls and other American liberal analytic political philosophers
was neglected in Portugal during the 1970s and 1980s. Second, the article describes
Portuguese reactions to Rawls’s ideas in the 1990s, focusing on commentaries by
scholars and ‘public intellectuals’. Throughout this period, there was a gradual shift
from glib partisan judgements to more careful responses. Third, the reception of
Rawls in Portugal is compared with the reception in Spain. This comparison shows
that both broad social context and the nature of academia tended to be more
hospitable to Rawls in Spain than in Portugal. However, the situation is changing.
key words: American, analytic, justice, liberal, philosophy, political, Portugal, Rawls,
reception, Spain
Portugal: The Context of Reception
When addressing the question of John Rawls’s influence in Portugal, the first
striking fact is the lack of influence for almost 20 years after the publication of
A Theory of Justice, in 1971.
1
However, the absence of references to Rawls in the
Portuguese philosophical and political literature of those years is not unique to
Rawls as an individual. This quasi-invisibility of Rawls in Portugal epitomizes a
long neglect in this country of the entire body of literature that Rawls helped to
create and shape since the beginning of the 1970s and that one may call ‘American
liberal analytic political philosophy’. Before beginning my account of the late
reception of Rawls in Portugal, I will examine the causes of this extended neglect.
From 1933 until 1974, Portugal was governed by a right-wing authoritarian
regime known as the New State, under which basic rights and liberties were
suppressed. The publication of books or any other printed works was tightly
controlled by an office of censorship, and universities were under surveillance by
the political police. During the New State period, several authors and university
243
article
Contact address: João Cardoso Rosas, Universidade do Minho, 4719 Braga, Portugal.
Email: rosas@ilch.uminho.pt
EJPT
European Journal
of Political Theory
© SAGE Publications Ltd,
London, Thousand Oaks
and New Delhi
issn 1474-8851
1( 2) 243–255; 0 27821