140 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NUCLEAR SCIENCE, VOL. 50, NO. 1, FEBRUARY 2003
High-Resolution X-ray Imaging Based on
Curved Bragg Mirrors: First Results
Uwe Bergmann, Marijana Ivanovic, Member, IEEE, Pieter Glatzel, and Stephen P. Cramer
Abstract—Small animal cancer imaging has drawn increased
attention over the last few years due to greater availability
of genetically modified mice, permitting the study of human
diseases in animal models. Submillimeter resolution would be of
great value to provide the fine detail needed in the imaging of
small tumors traced by radio-labeled agents. Despite extensive
research and improvements in instrumentation and imaging
reconstruction, until now, there has been no efficient technology
for this task. The limitations of scintillation cameras with pin-
hole collimators, currently the highest resolution devices, are
fundamental in nature. They include image blurring through
edge effects, scattering at the pinhole, and inelastic Compton
scattering. Furthermore, such devices often yield low efficiency.
In this paper, a new approach to high-resolution imaging of
radio-labeled agents is introduced and first results are shown.
The technique is based on curved perfect-crystal X-ray mirrors
applied in a one-to-one focusing geometry. Such Bragg diffraction
optics yields high reflectivity and excellent energy resolution
and it has been applied in X-ray spectroscopy for many years.
Today large perfect-crystal mirrors are commercially available
and efficient devices covering a substantial solid angle can be
envisioned. The potential advantage over conventional pinhole
cameras is twofold. First, focusing diffraction optics provides a
“virtual” pinhole, which can effectively be inside the object under
investigation and does not suffer from edge effects. Second, Bragg
optics has an energy resolution of a few eV and discriminates
against Compton scattering. The fundamentals of Bragg optics
are dicussed and first results using Fe and Tc phantoms are
presented. Our data show spatial resolutions of less than 1 and
2 mm, respectively. Current limitations of this new technique and
possible future designs are discussed.
Index Terms—Biomedical imaging, Bragg reflection, small an-
imal cancer imaging, X-rays, X-ray detectors, X-ray scattering.
I. INTRODUCTION
H
IGHER spatial resolution and sensitivity for small animal
imaging is continuously sought to improve the spatial
detail and image quality that can be obtained in radionuclide
imaging. Radionuclide imaging has profited from greater tissue
specificity and highly selective uptake of many of the new
labeled monoclonal antibodies, receptor specific molecules,
peptides, and other new radiopharmaceuticals [1]–[4]. These
Manuscript received January 3, 2002; revised August 15, 2002. This work
was supported in part by the Department of Health and Human Services, NIH
National Cancer Institute1 R21, under Grant 87499-01.
U. Bergmann and S. P. Cramer are with the Lawrence Berkley National
Laboratory, Berkley, CA 94720, USA, and also with the Department of Applied
Science, University of California, Davis, Davis, CA 95616 USA (e-mail:
ubergmann@lbl.gov).
M. Ivanovic is with the Department of Radiology, University of North Car-
olina, Chapel Hill, NC 27514 USA.
P. Glatzel is with the Department of Applied Science, University of California
Davis, Davis, CA 95616 USA.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TNS.2002.807884
advances also place new demands on imaging with high spatial
resolution in order to characterize regional localization and
turnover properties.
Planar imaging of the activity distribution of radiopharma-
ceuticals in small animals has been conventionally performed
using scintillation cameras with high-resolution, parallel hole
collimators or pinhole collimators. Although good spatial reso-
lution can be achieved with these techniques, only two-dimen-
sional images of three-dimensional activity distributions are ob-
tained and spatial detail and contrast are limited due to crosstalk
from activity in overlying or underlying tissues. Spatial reso-
lution of the order of 6–10 mm is obtained with high-resolu-
tion parallel hole collimators and 2–5 mm with pinhole colli-
mators. SPECT imaging with conventional parallel hole, fan, or
cone beam collimators can provide tomograms of the activity
distribution in three dimensions, however, the spatial resolution
achieved with these collimators is usually not adequate to pro-
vide the fine detail needed for many tissues and organs in small
laboratory animals. Spatial resolution of 1–3 mm is often sought
for these studies. As a result, considerable effort has been given
to identify and characterize new detectors and to modify more
conventional detectors to achieve greater spatial resolution and
adequate sensitivity [5]–[10].
In this work, we present first studies of a new approach to
high-resolution imaging of radio-labeled agents. The technique
is based on focusing X-ray optics using perfect crystal Bragg
mirrors. In the visible range imaging devices such as mirrors,
lenses, and wave-guides rely on the large refraction index of
glass or other materials. Due to the short wavelength of hard
X-rays and -rays condensed matter has, at these high frequen-
cies, generally an index of refraction somewhat smaller than, but
very close to one. As a consequence the critical angle for total
reflection is very small (of order mrad). Considering absorption
and stringent requirements on surface quality, focusing X-ray
optics based on many total reflections are not very efficient in
the hard X-ray regime. (Although there is an increased use of
capillary X-ray optics based on total reflection in the soft and
medium X-ray range).
A different way to reflect X-rays at much larger angles makes
use of diffraction from crystalline material. This so-called Bragg
optics is commonly used in X-ray spectroscopy. Large perfect
single crystals such as Si or Ge are grown routinely nowadays,
and curved X-ray Bragg mirrors have become larger as well
[11]. Due to the nature of Bragg reflections a curved Bragg
mirror can act like a monochromator and lens at the same time.
Thus, different from a -camera based on a real pinhole, a fo-
cusing Bragg mirror can provide a “virtual” pinhole. In the fol-
lowing section, we describe the principle of Bragg optics and in
0018-9499/03$17.00 © 2003 IEEE