Multimode Multidrop Serial Coalescence Effects during
Condensation on Hierarchical Superhydrophobic Surfaces
Konrad Rykaczewski,*
,†
Adam T. Paxson,
†
Sushant Anand,
†
Xuemei Chen,
‡
Zuankai Wang,
‡
and Kripa K. Varanasi*
,†
†
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139, United States
‡
Department of Mechanical and Biomedical Engineering, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: The prospect of enhancing the condensation rate by
decreasing the maximum drop departure diameter significantly
below the capillary length through spontaneous drop motion has
generated significant interest in condensation on superhydrophobic
surfaces (SHS). The mobile coalescence leading to spontaneous
drop motion was initially reported to occur only on hierarchical
SHS, consisting of both nanoscale and microscale topological
features. However, subsequent studies have shown that mobile
coalescence also occurs on solely nanostructured SHS. Thus, recent
focus has been on understanding the condensation process on
nanostructured surfaces rather than on hierarchical SHS. In this
work, we investigate the impact of microscale topography of hierarchical SHS on the droplet coalescence dynamics and wetting
states during the condensation process. We show that isolated mobile and immobile coalescence between two drops, almost
exclusively focused on in previous studies, are rare. We identify several new droplet shedding modes, which are aided by
tangential propulsion of mobile drops. These droplet shedding modes comprise of multiple droplets merging during serial
coalescence events, which culminate in formation of a drop that either departs or remains anchored to the surface. We directly
relate postmerging drop adhesion to formation of drops in nanoscale as well as microscale Wenzel and Cassie-Baxter wetting
states. We identify the optimal microscale feature spacing of the hierarchical SHS, which promotes departure of the highest
number of microdroplets. This optimal surface architecture consists of microscale features spaced close enough to enable
transition of larger droplets into micro-Cassie state yet, at the same time, provides sufficient spacing in-between the features for
occurrence of mobile coalescence.
■
INTRODUCTION
Development of passive methods to enhance water con-
densation rate could dramatically improve the energy efficiency
of power generation,
1-3
air conditioning systems,
4
water
desalination,
5,6
and water harvesting.
7-12
The rate of this
phase change process is largely limited by how quickly
condensate departs the surface.
13-19
For example, the steady
state condensation rate on hydrophobic surfaces, which
promote formation of easily shedding droplets, is significantly
higher than that on hydrophilic surfaces, which favor water film
formation (i.e., dropwise vs filmwise condensation mode). On
vertically inclined flat hydrophobic surfaces, hemispherical
drops grow via coalescence until reaching a diameter equal to
the water capillary length of about 2.7 mm.
13,16
Subsequently,
the drops slide off the surface due to gravity. Recently, Chen et
al.
20
and Dorrer and Ruhe
21
observed that during condensation
on properly designed superhydrophobic surfaces (SHS)
22
drops with sizes significantly below the capillary length can
depart the surface via spontaneous droplet motion.
2,20-30
The
prospect of enhancing the condensation rate by decreasing the
maximum departure diameter, which could double the heat
transfer rate,
2,13,16,31,32
has generated much interest and
research effort in condensation on SHS.
Boreyko and Chen
23
initially reported that hierarchical SHS,
which consist of both nanoscale and microscale topological
features, are necessary to promote spontaneous drop motion.
23
More recently this mode of condensation has also been
observed on solely nanostructured surfaces.
2,21,22,25,28,29,33,34
Rykaczewski et al.
22,35
found that the primary role of the
nanostructure is confinement of the base area of nucleating
droplets, which leads to formation of nearly spherical
microdroplets through contact angle increase. In a subsequent
work, Enright et al.
34
reached a similar conclusion by studying
the effect of the nanoscale SHS architecture on later stages of
microdroplet growth. Similarly, Liu et al.
36
found in their
theoretical study that the nanostructure is crucial for formation
of high contact angle microdroplets. Rykaczewski
35
demon-
strated that the forming droplets grow in purely constant base
area mode until reaching a contact angle of 130° to 150°. The
Received: October 27, 2012
Revised: December 13, 2012
Published: December 21, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/Langmuir
© 2012 American Chemical Society 881 dx.doi.org/10.1021/la304264g | Langmuir 2013, 29, 881-891