Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, Vol. 29, No. 3, 1999
Autism During Infancy: A Retrospective Video Analysis of
Sensory-Motor and Social Behaviors at 9-12 Months of Age
Grace T. Baranek1
This retrospective video study explored the usefulness of sensory-motor measures in addition
to social behaviors as early predictors of autism during infancy. Three groups included 11
children with autism, 10 with developmental disabilities, and 11 typically developing chil-
dren. Home videos were edited to obtain a 10-minute cross-section of situations at 9-12 months
for each subject. Using interval scoring, raters coded several behavioral categories (i.e., Look-
ing, Affect, Response to Name, Anticipatory Postures, Motor/Object Stereotypies, Social
Touch, Sensory Modulation). Nine items, in combination, were found to discriminate the three
groups with a correct classification rate of 93.75%. These findings indicate that subtle symp-
toms of autism are present at 9-12 months, and suggest that early assessment procedures need
to consider sensory processing/sensory-motor functions in addition to social responses during
infancy. Furthermore, prior to a time that they reported autistic symptoms, caregivers used
compensatory strategies to increase the saliency of stimuli in order to engage their children
more successfully; these strategies may provide a window for earlier diagnosis.
INTRODUCTION
An accurate diagnosis of autism appears reliable
no earlier than 2 to 3 years of age (e.g., Lord, 1995)
despite the overwhelming conviction that it is a neuro-
developmental disorder of prenatal origin (Bailey,
Phillips, & Rutter, 1996; Gillberg & Coleman, 1992;
Rutter & Schopler, 1987; Volkmar, Stier, & Cohen,
1985). The early elusiveness of autism leads to specu-
lation about whether symptoms actually do exist in
infancy and if so, whether they are too subtle to be
detected reliably. Earlier diagnosis appears limited by
(a) our knowledge of the early development in those
infants later diagnosed with autism, and (b) our reliance
on conventional classification systems (e.g., DSM-IV;
American Psychiatric Association [APA], 1994) based
1 Center for Development and Learning and Division of Occupational
Therapy, CB #7255, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill,
Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27599-7255; e-mail: gbaranek@css.
unc.edu
on the "triad" of behaviors (i.e., social, language,
and behavioral symptoms) manifested in older children
with autism. Both the presence of unusual behaviors
(e.g., stereotypies) as well as the absence of typically
developing behaviors (e.g., verbal language) are con-
sidered for diagnosis. Therefore, professionals are re-
luctant to diagnose autism prior to the age that a child
would typically develop representational capacities and
prior to expectations for production of consistent so-
cial initiatives such as sharing, offering comfort, and
initiating joint attention.
Moreover, the course of autistic symptomatology
may change considerably with age; thus, symptoms
during infancy may not appear at all like later mani-
festations of the disorder (Bailey et al, 1996; Gillberg
et al, 1990; Watson & Marcus, 1988). Research has
also shown that autistic symptoms are easier to recog-
nize as they intensify or become more pervasive with
age (Adrien et al., 1993; Lord, 1995; Wing, 1969), and
parents' awareness of symptoms also varies with their
child's stages of development (Stone & Hogan, 1993).
213
0162-3257/99/0600-0213S16.00/0 © 1999 Plenum Publishing Corporation
KEY WORDS: Home movies; autistic symptoms; developmental disabilities; early diagnosis; sensory
processing; social responsiveness.