Political Geography 93 (2022) 102526
0962-6298/© 2021 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
Full Length Article
Passing as a tourist: Exploring the everyday urban geopolitics of tourism
Marik Shtern
Postdoctoral Fellow, The Truman Institute for the Advancement of Peace, Department of Geography, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Tourism geopolitics
Performative tourism
Urban geopolitics
Contested cities
Israeli-Palestinian confict
Jerusalem
ABSTRACT
This paper presents a case study of territorial boundary transgression and intergroup encounters mediated by
tourism in a volatile and contested urban space. I present the notion of ‘passing as a tourist’ as a prism to
investigate the nexus between performative tourism and everyday urban geopolitics. Situated in East Jerusalem’s
core geographies of colonization and political violence, this paper uses archival news material and a textual
analysis of primary questionnaire data to critically examine how Jewish Israeli Jerusalemites visiting the Muslim
Quarter in the Old City negotiate encounters in a conficted space. The study reveals how the performative di-
mensions of ‘tourism’ in a context of polarized ethnonational division expose the role of embodied, everyday
geopolitics in the production of urban spaces of tourism.
1. Introduction
There is arguably no better exemplar of the constitutive relations
between urban geopolitics and tourism than Israel/Palestine. Since
1967, the Israeli government has leveraged domestic and international
tourism in the region to rebrand and normalize the state (Brin, 2006;
Gelbman, 2008; Isaac, Michael & Higgins-Desbiolles, 2015). A notable
example of this process is the ‘pink-washing’ of Tel-Aviv as a
gay-friendly urban utopia, which serves to reframe Israel’s international
image as a liberal country (Ram et al., 2019; Ritchie, 2015; Schulman,
2011). Another prominent instance is the contested tourist development
in Silwan, East Jerusalem. South of Jerusalem’s Old City, in the Pales-
tinian village of Silwan, the powerful, quasi-governmental Ir-David
Foundation (El’ad) has established a massive tourism destination
combining Zionist archeology with aggressive settler colonialism (Noy,
2013). This site, among others in Israel/Palestine, highlights the role of
politically oriented tourism as an important visitor draw, shaping both
Zionist and Palestinian political meta-narratives. Tourists’ positioning
within this context varies according to these visitors’ political ori-
entations—from neutral observers of geopolitical dynamics to active
partisans (Brin, 2006).
Notwithstanding discussion of the top-down institutional utilization
of tourism for the sake of geopolitical claim-making, the actual,
everyday manifestations of tourism geopolitics in Israel/Palestine have
not been thoroughly investigated. This paper addresses this lacuna by
interrogating the spatial practices of localized Jewish-Israeli tourism in
the Muslim Quarter of the Old City of Jerusalem. In the last two decades,
the Muslim Quarter has become an epicenter of Israeli colonization and
Palestinian resistance (Dumper, 2002, Isaac et al, 2015; Rokem, Weiss &
Midownik, 2018). Many Jewish Israelis ceased visiting the area
(Jabareen et al., 2019; Romann & Weingrod, 1991), fearing hostility and
physical harm. Yet some Jewish-Israeli Jerusalemites remain attracted
to the orientalist allure of East Jerusalem’s Arab cityscapes and tradi-
tional market fare. This paper explores the ways in which these visitors
navigate this contested territory in light of the perceived risk of (phys-
ical) political violence, as well as their conficted positionality as
Jewish-Israeli residents of Jerusalem within Palestinian spaces of the
Old City.
To encapsulate the ways in which Israeli visitors access and navigate
occupied Palestinian touristic localities, I suggest the concept of ‘passing
as a tourist.’ The notion of ‘passing’ has typically been applied with
reference to marginalized groups navigating spaces of socioeconomic
and racial exclusion (Ginsberg, 1996, pp. 1–18; Piper, 1992; Kawash,
1996). While cognizant of the hardships imposed upon Palestinians
trying to move throughout Jerusalem (Greenber-Raanan & Avni, 2020),
in this case study, I focus on the spatio-performative practices that
enable Jewish Israelis to experience a sense of legitimacy and security
when visiting historical and culinary destinations in the Muslim Quarter.
The right to pass as a tourist, in this asymmetric political context, is a
privilege, but also a sign of weakness. When local residents intentionally
embody the social category of tourist in order to establish a sense of
safety and belonging within parts of their city, it indicates an essential
foreignness within this arena. Within complex spatial dialectics of in-
clusion and exclusion, the tourist performance emerges as a mediating
space of encounter between colonizer and colonized, between insider
and outsider, between communities simultaneously contesting and
E-mail address: marik.shtern@mail.huji.ac.il.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Political Geography
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/polgeo
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2021.102526
Received 30 April 2020; Received in revised form 9 August 2021; Accepted 15 October 2021