S. Yamamoto (Ed.): HIMI 2014, Part I, LNCS 8521, pp. 34–43, 2014.
© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2014
A Post-simulation Assessment Tool for Training
of Air Traffic Controllers
Aslak Wegner Eide, Stian Støer Ødegård, and Amela Karahasanović
SINTEF, Oslo, Norway
{aslak.eide,amela.karahasanovic}@sintef.no,
stiancid@outlook.com
Abstract. This paper proposes a post-simulation assessment tool that aims to
improve the training of air traffic controllers (ATCOs) by visualizing their per-
formance. The tool helps the controllers to identify bottlenecks in flight traffic
and find alternative solutions that might improve traffic throughput. The useful-
ness of the tool was evaluated in a study involving benchmark tests and inter-
views with five experienced ATCOs. The results from the study indicate that
the tool can help ATCO students to (1) identify irregularities in their work, (2)
find possible underlying causes of these irregularities, and (3) find alternative
solutions preventing these irregularities. Visual feedback consisting of work-
flow graphs and radar replays might generate valuable insights that enable self
and peer assessment during ATCO training. Our results might be interesting
both for the practitioners working with ATCO training and for researcher inves-
tigating the effects of visualization in education.
Keywords: visualization, air traffic control, training, real-time simulation.
1 Introduction
The continuously growing demand in air transport has heightened the need to improve
productivity in air traffic control. Coping with this challenge requires not only new
automation tools and enhanced procedures, but also a rethinking of air traffic control-
lers (ATCOs) training [1-2]. In order to achieve the required learning effects, existing
training programs need to integrate hands-on training with knowledge acquisition and
skill development [3]. Training should not only teach users how new tools should be
used, but also help overcome resistance to change.
In today's practice, real-time simulation (RTS) of work scenarios is regularly used
as a cost-effective way of training new and experienced ATCOs. One of the great
advantages of RTS, compared with other learning aids, is the ability to freeze and
replay scenarios directly, enabling instructors to provide timely feedback on a given
traffic situation and on the quality of the decisions made by the trainee [4]. However,
the delivery of such feedback requires the full attention of an instructor, and may also
cause disruptions in the internal planning process of the trainees, making it difficult
for them to progress and positively reinforce their learned skills [5]. Furthermore,
shortage of time, inadequacy of the feedback, fear of failure, and negative environ-
ments might also cause problems during the ATCOs training [5].