NATURE GEOSCIENCE | VOL 6 | NOVEMBER 2013 | www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 905
T
he sub-continental lithospheric mantle (SCLM; Box 1) formed
in the mid–late Archaean eon
1–5
and changed the face of the
Earth. By providing stable continental shelves, or cratons, on
an Earth foored by oceanic crust, the SCLM forced a signifcant
reorganization of plate tectonics. Te regions surrounding the cra-
tons became fractured to form peri-cratonic basins, and disconti-
nuities in the SCLM acted as physical guides for magma upwelling
from the convecting mantle below. Te SCLM provided a durable,
buoyant and rigid reservoir for ore-forming elements, and enabled
the preservation of the overlying crust and attendant ore deposits.
Te role of the SCLM in generating giant ore deposits is strongly
debated. Here we review the characteristics of some diamond, plati-
num-group elements (PGE), Ni-Cu-(PGE) and (Cu-)Au ore depos-
its worldwide, and argue that the history, structure and evolution of
the SCLM may be directly relevant to the genesis and localization
of some of these deposits. We therefore suggest that mapping of the
SCLM structure, age and composition should form a key compo-
nent of mineral exploration programmes.
The sub-continental lithospheric mantle
Te origins of the SCLM are controversial
1,6–9
. A common view
7,8
suggests that SCLM was built up mostly from subducted oceanic
slabs that were depleted in many elements, because of shallow
melting at ocean ridges and in subduction zones. A newer view
5,9
,
however, suggests that the SCLM formed from the residues of very
high-degree melting, either in plumes rising from the deep man-
tle
1,5
or through high-temperature melting of the ambient upper
mantle
4
. Evidence for formation of the SCLM by high-degree melt-
ing is provided by observations of the Fe-depleted compositions
(FeO < 7 wt%) of many kimberlite-borne, SCLM-derived perido-
tites that have no counterparts in modern oceanic mantle
1,9
.
Te initial SCLM was highly depleted in magmaphile elements
and has been preserved largely due to the buoyancy imparted by
its low iron-to-magnesium ratio. Since the SCLM formed, fuids
and magmas derived from the convecting mantle have ponded at
its base or ascended via weak zones such as craton boundaries and
large faults. Tese magmas and fuids have progressively replenished
the SCLM (a process known as metasomatic refertilization) in mag-
maphile elements, including components of ore deposits, such as
Cu and Au. Refertilization may be especially intense where cratons
Continental-root control on the genesis of
magmatic ore deposits
W. L. Grifn
1
*, G. C. Begg
1,2
and Suzanne Y. O’Reilly
1
Giant magma-related ore systems are prime targets for modern mineral exploration, yet it is unclear what controls their
formation. The magmas originate in Earth’s convecting mantle. To reach the surface, they must pass through the stagnant
sub-continental lithospheric mantle, but the role of this mantle in ore genesis is vigorously debated. In one view, the ascending
magmas are already metal-rich and the sub-continental lithospheric mantle acts only as a passive, buoyant raft on which the
continental crust — the fnal store for the ore deposits — rides. Here we argue that the sub-continental lithospheric mantle may
actually contain ore-forming elements that could be entrained by ascending magmas, and that it therefore plays a signifcant
role in the genesis of magmatic ore. Specifcally, we suggest that some types of magma pick up ore-forming components, such
as diamonds and gold, and possibly platinum-group elements, during their passage through the mantle lithosphere, and that
the three-dimensional structure of the lithosphere helps to focus deposition of the ore. We therefore suggest that models for
ore genesis and exploration need to incorporate the entire lithosphere to be efective.
were bordered by subduction zones at some stage of their evolution,
because subduction zones provide a supply of fuids. Progressive
refertilization has changed the concentrations of major elements
and trace elements (as well as their isotopic compositions
10,11
) in the
SCLM. Te most common rocks of the deep SCLM (garnet lherzo-
lites) are strongly metasomatized, and carry little information that
could be used to support a shallow origin for the SCLM.
Ongoing studies
12,13
are integrating geophysics with mantle geo-
chemistry and geochronology to map the distribution and age of
upper-lithospheric domains to depths ≥100 km (Fig. 1). Te results
imply that at least 70% of all SCLM worldwide was formed in a short
period 3.0 to 3.5 Gyr ago
1,2
(billion years ago; Ga) and has resided
beneath the continents ever since. Similarly, Hf-isotope analyses of
crustal zircons
14
indicate that >60% of existing continental crust
was generated >2.5 Ga, and has been progressively re-melted and
reconstituted in later tectonic episodes. Physical and temporal links
between crust and mantle
1,5,12
suggest that large-scale mantle melt-
ing produced not only the cratonic SCLM but much of the original
continental crust too.
Ore deposit links with SCLM structure and composition
Diamond deposits. Primary diamond deposits provide a compel-
ling example of SCLM control on magma emplacement, and hence
on the distribution of ore deposits. Te diamonds occur in dykes
and pipes of highly alkaline magmas (kimberlites and lamproites)
that are generated by low-volume melting near or below the base
of the SCLM. Te magmas pick up diamonds from the deep SCLM
(>150 km) during their eruption
7
.
Blocks of cratonic SCLM can be imaged by seismic tomography
and magnetotelluric surveys
15,16
as volumes with high seismic veloc-
ity (due to Fe depletion) and high electrical resistivity. On the large
scale (Fig. 2a), kimberlites and other low-volume mantle melts are
concentrated near the edges of cratonic blocks. High-resolution
seismic tomography (Fig. 2b) shows even more striking correlations;
most kimberlites cluster on the edges of high-velocity domains in
the deep SCLM. Te correlation is easily understood in geochemi-
cal and geophysical terms. Diamond formation requires the metaso-
matic re-introduction of carbon into the originally depleted SCLM.
Te carbon is typically accompanied by elements such as Ca, Al,
K, Na and Fe (refs 10,11), producing lower seismic velocities in the
1
ARC Centre of Excellence for Core to Crust Fluid Systems/GEMOC, Macquarie University, NSW 2109, Australia,
2
Minerals Targeting International PL,
17 Prowse St, West Perth, Western Australia 6005, Australia. *e-mail: bill.grifn@mq.edu.au
FOCUS
|
PERSPECTIVE
PUBLISHED ONLINE: 13 OCTOBER 2013 | DOI: 10.1038/NGEO1954
© 2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved