Analysis of Various Partitioning Strategies for Multi-
Agent System-Based Real-Time Load Management for
NG IPS Ships
Xianyong Feng, Karen L. Butler-Purry, and Takis Zourntos
Dept. of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Texas A&M University
College Station, TX 77843, USA
Email: fxy8410@neo.tamu.edu, klbutler@tamu.edu, and takis@neo.tamu.edu
Abstract—The real-time load management techniques for next
generation integrated power systems (NG IPS) for ships are
being developed to balance the load demand and the power
generation while satisfying the operating constraints of the
system in real-time. To solve the real-time load management
problem using a multi-agent system cooperative control
protocol, the NG IPS must be partitioned into smaller
subsystems that are modeled using dynamical agents. In this
paper, three potential partitioning strategies are discussed along
with their advantages and disadvantages. Unlike the first
partitioning strategy modeling half a zone as an agent which
aggregates a group of loads together, the last partitioning
strategy models an agent for each electrical component and
includes more system dynamics, which significantly increases
the agent model accuracy. The results of the studies of the
partitioning strategies can be utilized during the cooperative
controller design to achieve real-time load management for NG
IPS ships.
Index Terms—Cooperative control, multi-agent system, next
generation integrated power system, partitioning strategy, real-
time load management
I. INTRODUCTION
The Power System Automation Lab at Texas A&M
University has been conducting research on real-time load
management techniques for NG IPS ships for several years
[1], [2]. Real-time load management techniques can be used to
balance the load demand and the power generation of power
systems while satisfying the operating constraints of the
system in real-time [1]. Since the NG IPS is a very complex
dynamical system which is hundreds to thousands of orders, it
is difficult to solve the real-time load management problem
using a single controller or traditional optimization methods.
A multi-agent system aims to cooperatively achieve the group
objectives which are difficult to reach by a single agent or
controller [3]. Thus, a multi-agent system cooperative control
protocol is being developed to cooperatively achieve the real-
time load management objectives based on a group of
dynamical agents. In order to use the dynamical multi-agent
system, the power system needs to be partitioned into smaller
subsystems, which can be managed using dynamical
autonomous agents. The nature of the system such as the
topology of the system indicates a logical way to partition the
system, which can make the multi-agent system more
effective.
The NG IPS system includes gas turbine generators,
transformers, cables, power converters, propulsion loads, and
DC zones which have similar topologies. If the notional NG
IPS model is partitioned based on the topology of the NG IPS
such as DC zones or DC-DC converters, a group of
homogeneous subsystems is obtained. On the other hand, if
the system is partitioned based on the individual electrical
components, a group of heterogeneous subsystems is obtained.
For the homogeneous multi-agent system, each agent has an
identical dynamical model which may be modeled as a single
integrator system [4], double integrator system [5], coupled-
phase oscillator system [6], non-holonomic agent system [7],
etc. The multi-agent system cooperative control protocol for
the lower order (no more than second order) agent model has
been systematically studied [3], [8]. For the higher order (third
order or higher) agent model, only consensus algorithms [9],
[10] and formation control [11] for linear agent model have
been studied.
For the heterogeneous multi-agent system, each agent has
a different dynamical model which makes the cooperative
control design more complicated. The formation control and
cooperative control for the heterogeneous multi-agent systems
have been studied in [12], [13]. However, these control
methods can only be used to handle certain types of dynamical
agent models. The notional NG IPS model includes different
individual electrical components such as generators,
propulsion loads, converters, and motor loads, which have
totally different types of dynamical models. Thus, there are
This work was supported in part by the Office of Naval Research under
Grant N00014-09-1-0579.
978-1-4244-9273-2/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE 173