Atrial Transplantation for Recurrent
Cardiac Sarcoma
Serban C. Stoica, AFRCS,
a
Ian M. Mitchell, MD, FRCS (CTh),
b
James Foreman, FIBMS,
c
Charles J. Hunt, PhD,
c
John Wallwork, FRCS,
a
and Stephen R. Large, FRCP, FRCS
a
Cardiac transplantation for sarcomas has met with little success and the surgical
treatment remains controversial. We describe the case of a 56-year-old woman who was
referred for transplantation after two procedures in which undifferentiated atrial
sarcoma was locally excised successfully. The patient underwent atrial homograft
transplantation, the first reported to date. Advantages of the procedure include wide
atrial resection and no need for immune suppression. J Heart Lung Transplant 2001;
20:1220–1223.
Cardiac sarcomas are the second most common
tumors of the heart after myxomas. The diagnostic
and especially the therapeutic difficulties have been
reviewed elsewhere.
1–4
Excision is associated with
high rates of recurrence. Cardiac transplantation is
traditionally contraindicated in patients with malig-
nant disease of the heart or other organs. Some
investigators have been attracted by the concept of
replacing the heart in patients with malignancy
localized to the heart and no detectable systemic
dissemination.
3–6
Babatasi et al summarized the
world experience of 8 cases of heart transplantation
for sarcoma with a median survival of 9 months.
7
This is better than the dismal natural history of
untreated disease, and also better than the results of
resection alone or as part of a combined modality
treatment. The median post-operative survival for
resection of left-sided leiomyosarcomas is 6.8
months.
7,8
As with other malignancies of the heart
treated by transplantation, the optimal immunosup-
pression protocol is unknown.
9
Sub-optimal immu-
nosuppression calls for rejection and compromises
the allograft, whereas conventional doses increase
the risk of accelerated manifestation of any meta-
static disease. Adjuvant therapies are not without
problems either; for instance, radiotherapy to the
mediastinum or any chemotherapeutic regimen with
cardiotoxic drugs may increase the injury burden to
the cardiac allograft.
10
In this context, we present our experience with a
case of recurrent sarcoma of the left atrium treated
by atrial homograft transplantation. Locally ad-
vanced disease prevented us from obtaining a good
result. However, the availability of atrial homograft,
the technical feasibility of the operation and the lack
of need for post-operative immunosuppression
make the procedure an interesting therapeutic op-
tion.
CASE REPORT
In 1996, a 56-year-old previously healthy woman
presented to her local hospital with symptoms of
slowly progressing dyspnea. Echocardiography
demonstrated a dumb-bell tumor growing across
the atrial septum and she underwent resection of
the lesion and reconstruction of septum with
autologous pericardium. A small nodule from the
posterior leaflet of the mitral valve was also
excised. The histology report surprisingly showed
undifferentiated sarcoma in all the components of
the specimen. A year later, during regular echo-
cardiographic follow-up, she was found to have
recurrence of tumor in the left atrium (LA). At a
second operation, a broad-based lesion was found
to have arisen from the posterolateral aspect of
From the
a
Department of Cardiothoracic Surgery and Transplan-
tation, Papworth Hospital, Cambridge, UK;
b
Department of
Cardiothoracic Surgery, Nottingham City Hospital, Notting-
ham, UK; and
c
The East Anglia Tissue Bank, Cambridge, UK.
Submitted November 10, 2000; accepted April 2, 2001.
Reprint requests: Dr. Stephen R. Large, Papworth Hospital,
Papworth Everard Cambridge CB3 8RE, UK. Telephone:
+44-01480-830541. Fax: +44-01480-364334. E-mail:
stephenrlarge@hotmail.com
Copyright © 2001 by the International Society for Heart and
Lung Transplantation.
1053-2498/01/$–see front matter PII S1053-2498(01)00306-0
1220