Original Article
Organ-preserving multimodality management of
squamous cell carcinoma of anal canal
S V S Deo, N K Shukla, V Raina,* B K Mohanti,**
Rajeev Sharan, Madhabananda Kar, G K Rath*
Departments of Surgical Oncology, **Medical Oncology and *Radiation Oncology,
Institute Rotary Cancer Hospital, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi 110 029
Aim: To study the efficacy of an organ-preserving,
sequential chemoradiation therapy for squamous cell
carcinoma of the anal canal, and of salvage surgery
in those in whom this treatment fails. Methods: Forty
biopsy-proven untreated patients (28 men) with
squamous cell carcinoma of the anal canal received
two cycles of chemotherapy using cisplatin and
methotrexate, followed by 45 to 60 (median 50) Gy
external beam radiotherapy. Salvage surgery was
offered to those in whom this treatment failed. Overall
survival, disease-free survival and colostomy-free survival
were analyzed. Results: Most patients (n=35; 87%)
had T3 or T4 lesions and 5 (12.5%) had involvement
of inguinal nodes. Thirty-one patients (77.5%) had
complete response after chemoradiation. Only three
patients (7.5%) developed chemotherapy-related grade
3 mucositis and myelosuppression. Radiotherapy-
related toxicity included grade III cystitis in one patient
and grade III proctitis in three patients. Three patients
had post-treatment anal stenosis requiring repeated
dilatation and two had chronic non-healing ulcers at
the anal verge. Nine patients had failure of
chemoradiation or disease recurrence; of these, only
5 could undergo salvage surgery. After a median
follow up of 60 months, overall survival, disease-free
survival and colostomy-free survival were 80%, 77.5%
and 72.5%, respectively. Conclusion: Chemoradiation
is effective in the treatment of squamous cell anal
cancer and has acceptable toxicity. Surgical salvage
may be useful in those with failure of this treatment.
[Indian J Gastroenterol 2005;24:201-204]
A
nal cancer (AC) accounts for 1%-2% of all large
bowel cancers. During the last three decades,
the standard of care in this disease has shifted from
radical surgery to organ-preserving chemoradiation-
based protocols.
1
The 5-year survival rate in patients
with AC after radical surgery like abdomino-perineal
resection alone was only 40%-60%.
2
Combined-
modality approach (CMT), which was initially
propagated by Nigro et al
3
in 1974 as a pre-operative
regimen, has now evolved into a stand-alone treatment
Copyright © 2005 by Indian Society of Gastroenterology
program.
4,5
Using this treatment, complete and
sustained tumor eradication with sphincter preservation
has been reported in 75%-90% of patients with AC.
5,6,7
Therefore, the role of surgery in patients with AC is
now limited to salvaging those who fail CMT.
5,6,8
In
this study, we looked at the results of combined
chemoradiotherapy in patients with AC.
Methods
Between 1990 and 1997, 68 previously untreated
patients with AC attended the Gastrointestinal Can-
cer Clinic. Of these, 28 patients had metastatic dis-
ease, significant co-morbid conditions, Kornofsky
performance score below 70, or adenocarcinoma,
and were excluded. The remaining 40 patients were
included in the study and were followed up till 2004.
All patients underwent clinical and proctoscopic
examination of the anal canal and rectum. Computed
tomography examination of the abdomen and pelvis,
chest X-ray, hemogram, and renal and liver function
tests were done. Punch biopsy of the primary growth
and fine-needle aspiration cytology of suspicious lymph
nodes in the groin was done. Ethical clearance was
obtained from the institution and all patients gave
informed consent for inclusion in this protocol be-
fore start of treatment.
A sequential chemoradiotherapy protocol using
2 cycles of chemotherapy followed by radiotherapy
was followed. Patients with either no response or
presence of residual disease were considered for
salvage surgery.
Chemotherapy protocol
Chemotherapy consisted of two cycles of intrave-
nous cisplatin 30 mg/m
2
for three days and intrave-
nous methotrexate 200 mg/m
2
given as a bolus on
day 1, with parenteral hydration of at least 1 liter.
Sufficient hydration was done to ensure urinary output
of 100 mL per hour during and 4 hours after the
infusion of cisplatin. Anti-emetic drugs were admin-
istered during chemotherapy. The cycle was repeated
after three weeks.