280
Introduction
Increasng competton among stakeholders for
lmted water resources, combned wth the relatve
absence of new and cheaper water resources, have led
to the need for sustanable water resources systems.
Sustanable water resources systems are desgned and
managed to contrib�te to the aims and objectives o the
socety, now and n the future, whle mantanng ther
ecologcal, envronmental, and hydrologcal ntegrty
(ASE, 1998; U�ESO, 1999). To have s�stainable
water resources systems, t s necessary to rank
�ater reso�rces projects, especiall inter-basin �ater
transfers:
• To cope �ith limited �ater, nancial and h�man
reso�rces;
• To allow for mult crtera decson�makng
instead o single criterion decision-making;
• To avod the opportunty costs of delay n
decision- making;
• To resolve conict among stakeholders; and s; and
• To simpli the administration o projects. o projects.
Besdes techncal functons, the choce among
alternative �ater reso�rces projects is generall based
Fuzzy Multiple Attribute Decision Making on Water
Resources Projects Case Study: Ranking Water Transfers to
Zayanderud Basin in Iran
Mahdi Zarghaami, Reza Ardakanian, Department of Civil Engineering, Sharif University
of Technology, Tehran, Iran, and Azizolah Memariani Department of
Industrial Engineering, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran
Abstract: In this study, in order to create a decision-making model on water resources projects, a hierarchy
of criteria has been developed by public participation. The Value Management methodology has been used for
extraction of the effective criteria and attributes in the scope of Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM).
The hierarchy is generic for water resources management in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Since the evaluations of
alternatives with respect to some attributes are uncertain and vague, fuzzy set theory has been used. By merging
fuzzy set theory and multi-attribute decision-making a new Decision Support System (DSS), namely FDM, has
been developed to compare different alternatives. As an innovation, FDM accepts evaluations of alternatives with
respect to the attributes as crisp variables, fuzzy variables, and linguistic variables. FDM embodies an expert
system whose duty is to choose an appropriate method among the SAW, Fuzzy SAW, TOPSIS or Fuzzy TOPSIS
based on the characteristics of the problem.
The central and Southeastern regions of Iran are considered arid regions, suffering from water
shortages. In this paper, water transfers to the Zayanderud basin in Iran have been modeled by FDM. Successful
application of this DSS in this study allows for its application by water authorities in other case studies.
Keywords: inter-basin water transfer, hierarchy of criteria, multi attribute decision making, fuzzy set
theory, DSS.
Internatonal Water Resources Assocaton
Water International, Volume 32, Number 2, Pg. 280�293, June 2007
© 2007 Internatonal Water Resources Assocaton