Proceedings of ICONE15:
15th International Conference on Nuclear Engineering
April 22-26, 2007, Nagoya, Japan
ICONE15-10707
OPERATIONAL PERFORMANCE INDICATORS OF PWR STEAM
GENERATORS
T. Viglasky R. Awad S. Milivojevic
Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission Vinca Institute of Sciences
P.O.B 1046, Station B P.O.B 1046, Station B P.O.B. 511
Ottawa, ON K1P 5S9, CANADA Ottawa, ON K1P 5S9, CANADA Belgrade 11000, Serbia
(613) 995-2503 (613) 995-2759 (+381)-1-2458-070
tom.viglasky@cnsc-ccsn.gc.ca raoul.awad@cnsc-ccsn.gc.ca
J. Riznic
Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission
P.O.B 1046, Station B
Ottawa, ON K1P 5S9, CANADA
(613) 943-0132
jovica.riznic@cnsc-ccsn.gc.ca
Keywords: steam generators, reliability, failure, operational performance, PWR reactors.
ABSTRACT
In the early days of design of generation I, II or III nuclear
power plants, it was assumed that the operational life cycle
of steam generators would be the same or similar to that of
the other key components in the reactor primary heat
transport system (reactor vessel, core, piping, primary
coolant pumps, etc.). However, the widespread
degradation of the steam generator tubing that has occurred
at a number of plants has shown this original assumption
was incorrect or at least too optimistic. Traditionally, the
tube plugging rate is the most commonly used indicator of
the extent of tube degradation and overall steam generator
fitness-for-service. However, the tube plugging rate does
not provide a complete picture about the extent of
degradation and its impact on steam generator and power
plant performance. This paper seeks to identify the more
appropriate steam generator performance indicators, namely
the steam generator failure rate and the steam generator
repair rate.
In this paper we analyzed the performance history of steam
generators in operation, e.g., their malfunctions during the
plant life cycle, with the aim of identifying characteristics of
failure rate and repair rate. These are necessary parameters
to determine the reliability and availability of steam
generators and their effect on the safety and efficiency of the
nuclear power plant. The raw data used in this analysis
come from experience at various nuclear power plants
collected in the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
Power Reactor Information System (PRIS) and published in
the Agency’s annual reports on operating experience since
1971. In total, data for 799 steam generators (SG) from
the onset of their commercial operation up to year 2000 were
analyzed. The analysis of SG performance indicators was
performed along two timeframes: over unit lifetime and over
calendar years. The data on steam generator failures are
presented in uniform format, allowing for the consistency in
failure classification and data reporting. Operational
performance of the analyzed steam generators is tracked
through a plant lifetime and the failure rate λ and repair rate
μ with associated boundaries were calculated. The
empirical probability distribution of failure rates and repair
rates were observed and general trends in performance
indicators (λ, μ) analyzed, from the point of their influence
on plant reliability and availability.
1. INTRODUCTION
The steam generators (SG) in pressurized water reactor
Copyright © 2007 by JSME
1